LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

Good post is good post

CreativeCOW presents Good post is good post -- Business & Marketing Editorial


CreativeCOW.net
Oahu Hawaii USA
CreativeCOW.net. All rights reserved.


Listen up. Good post is good post. Bad post is bad post. I mention this as a reminder to everyone saying that the only way to make a 3D movie is in the camera, that the "problem" with some 3D movies is that the 3D was added in post. It shouldn't take a single second for you to remember that post, in itself, is not the problem. Quite the contrary. We can all name a dozen examples off the top of our heads where post was the only possible solution to a problem, or the only possible way to create a scene, or simply the best way to bring a creative vision to fruition. It adds flexibility. You can fix things there.

I've been stopping strangers on the street, grabbing their lapels and yelling this in their face to little avail. But I digress.

This particular rant was motivated by comments I heard regarding "Piranha 3D." I confess that I missed it in theaters, so the only comment I have to make about it is that I eagerly await the Director's Cut on Blu-ray. But there has been this idea that the after-the-factness of the 3D for this and other recent pictures, is too artificial to ever overcome. You know it's a movie, right? It's all artificial. There were no real piranhas, either — but that kind of thing somehow never comes up.

No, as you start to read between the lines, you see why: the problem isn't 3D in post. It has simply become de rigeur, certainly among people who regularly say "de rigeur," to be aggressively negative about 3D at all.

There's considerable furrowing of the brow among such folks that 3D is distracting, if not painful to watch, and that it will never be appropriate for mainstream movies, because that kind of artificiality gets in the way of the artificiality we approve of. For such scowlers, I have two pieces of advice. First, cut it out. Your face is going to stick that way. Second, consider the history of color in movies, which has taken a remarkably similar path.

Early color cinematography required an expensive beam-splitting camera -- stop me if you've heard this one before -- and complicated projection schemes that failed more often than they succeeded. Technicolor founder H.T. Kalmus ironically lamented of the early days, "It was a terrible headache."

Douglas Fairbanks famously recounted the "overwhelming objections" to his strong support of color cinema: "The argument has been that it would tire and distract the eye, take attention from acting, and facial expression, blur and confuse the action. In short it has been felt that it would militate against the simplicity and directness which motion pictures derive from the unobtrusive black and white."

Ringing any bells? These things take time. Ten years after it was common in movie production, only 40% of American theaters could actually play sound. Even though it wouldn't be pervasive for another dozen years, the first color telecast was the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade (how could it have been anything else?) in 1954. That same year, barely over 50% of films were shot in color.

I don't have any particular moral to draw from this, except to recall that today's vigorous objection invariably becomes tomorrow's "Whatever, dude." I'm always going to place my bets on the people trying to get it right, rather than the people saying it shouldn't be done at all.

What does that have to do with asset management and distribution, you ask? Nothing. I just needed to get this off my chest. I can now invite you to read another remarkable set of stories from creative pros at the top of their game with a lighter heart, far less likely to accost random strangers in the street.

###

Comments

Re: Good post is good post
by Zack Clevenger
Agreed Tim. I think the 3D topic only took light because of the current climate. But I'm sure we all feel the same way about how many individuals tend to view our profession. I know I've had to argue my case more times than I should have. But alas, I'll fight for what I love.
Re: Good post is good post
by Tim Wilson
The point of this isn't how you feel about 3D. It's how you feel about post. The first criticism people make about many films is that the 3D is added in post, which, taken to its conclusion, means that authentic filmmaking ends with the camera. Everything in post is fraud, incompetence or both.

We can disagree on the validity and viability of 3D (and we do), but I think it's imperative that we, of all people, not fall into lockstep with the idea that post is the problem. I hear post pros say this all the time, and it saddens me that they have so little respect for their craft that they don't speak out, or at the very least are comfortable falling into line with a pathetic cliche.
Re: Good post is good post
by Zack Clevenger
To a degree I adhere to both sides of the story. In its current form I despise 3D. I find for me personally it induces headaches and (obtrusive 3D) distracts from the main purpose of any film or broadcast, which is to tell the story. However, that being said 3D has been around and will continue to evolve in order to "wow" its audiences. So even though I feel its still too early to gauge whether or not it will follow the way of other "Dodo birds" in our industry or not, the only way it can get better is to keep plugging away at it and continue to strive to improve. It's had many era's and though it goes away for a time it inevitably keeps coming back getting a little better with each resurgence. Maybe next time the glasses will finally disappear.
Re: Good post is good post
by Xavier de Champs
Hehe.
My take is: 3D will end up in the same cemetary as Binaural Recordings, Laser Discs, Virtual Reality and all other 3D attempts.

:)


Related Articles / Tutorials:
Business & Career Building
How To Succeed in the Business of Video Storytelling

How To Succeed in the Business of Video Storytelling

You may have great storytelling chops, but it doesn’t matter if you can't help your client tell theirs. Nobody knows this better than Rob Shore, who began his filmmaking career in 2005, honing his skills as a creative director with an in-house video team in Washington D.C. before establishing his own video production company, Picture This Productions in 2015. Adobe's Eric Philpott spoke to Rob about the challenges of storytelling when it’s someone else’s story.


Eric Philpott
Business & Career Building
Steps for Having Your Clients' Videos Translated

Steps for Having Your Clients' Videos Translated

Business owner and Creative COW member since 2001 (!!!) Greg Ball has been providing translation services for everything from commercials to children's cartoons to feature films and episodic TV, and seen it make a real difference to these projects' success and his own bottom line.? Greg breaks it all down for you, including the pluses and minuses of subtitling and dubbing, and of outsourcing or managing the process yourself.

Tutorial
Greg Ball
Business & Career Building
Graduating into Uncertainty: Encouragement for 2020 Media Grads

Graduating into Uncertainty: Encouragement for 2020 Media Grads

So you’re graduating into a pandemic and a recessed economy. Hoo boy. As a Spring 2009 media program graduate, I have a feeling what’s going through your head right now and yeah, it’s not great is it? I’m sorry about this timing. It sucks.

Editorial, Feature, People / Interview, Business
Kylee Peña
Business & Career Building
Go Creative Show: Build Your Filmmaking Career With YouTube

Go Creative Show: Build Your Filmmaking Career With YouTube

Discover how to advance your filmmaking and photography career on YouTube and Instagram in our interview with YouTuber and podcaster Tyler Stalman. Tyler and Go Creative Show host, Ben Consoli, discuss what it takes to stand out on YouTube, Tyler’s experience going from a stock photographer to freelance cinematographer, why it’s helpful to have a wide skillset of services, and much more!


Ben Consoli
Business & Career Building
31 New Year's Resolutions For Creatives: Make This Your Best Year Ever!

31 New Year's Resolutions For Creatives: Make This Your Best Year Ever!

What's it going to take to make this your best year ever? Specific steps. Business owner, author, video producer, photographer, and longtime Creative COW leader Richard Harrington is here to offer you 31 resolutions for the new year that can make a huge difference in your business, your life, and your creative potential, even if you just pick one of them. Make progress on all of them, and there are no limits to what you can achieve!


Richard Harrington
Business & Career Building
Four Secrets to Stock Video Sales Success

Four Secrets to Stock Video Sales Success

A successful stock video sales business, even if only part-time, relies heavily on the old adage, “practice makes perfect”. It’s a continual process of improving what you capture, how you capture it, and then how you market your stock video sales. Here are four strategies you can use to increase your sales.


Rod Harlan
Business & Career Building
Vimeo Stock Essentials: 1000+ Clips/$60K Value Now Included

Vimeo Stock Essentials: 1000+ Clips/$60K Value Now Included

Following the announcement of Vimeo Stock reaching the one million clip milestone, Vimeo today announces Vimeo Stock Essentials, a carefully curated collection of 1000+ clips in a variety of the most popular categories, now included as part of every annual Vimeo subscription at no additional cost, a value of over $60,000. We spoke with Vimeo's VP of Creator Programs and Vimeo Stock Derick Rhodes for details on Vimeo Stock Essentials, and Vimeo's vision as a company that cares about helping creators get things done.


Tim Wilson
Business & Career Building
Luck: A True Hollywood Story

Luck: A True Hollywood Story

It’s all about who you know, right? But what if you don't know anyone? Yoni Rusnak didn't come to Hollywood until nearly 30, not knowing anyone, yet is rapidly building an enviable resume in both scripted and unscripted TV. He's found that you CAN create luck, using a formula for breaking into the business that everyone can use, in Hollywood or anywhere else.

Feature
Yoni Rusnak
Business & Marketing
Media after Millennials: A Teen’s Research on Viewing Habits

Media after Millennials: A Teen’s Research on Viewing Habits

As a fifteen year old high school sophomore, Helen Ludé has her priorities in order: varsity soccer, Snapchat and Instagram, and presenting research on Post-Millennial Media and Cinema Consumption Habits at SMPTE’s Future of Cinema Conference. Spurred on by a dinner conversation with her family (including her father, RealD’s Peter Ludé), Helen conducted a survey of her peers to uncover the viewing habits of her generation, otherwise known as Gen Z. You're going to be surprised by what she found, and deeply impressed (and a little intimidated) by this enterprising young woman.

Feature, People / Interview
Kylee Peña
Business & Marketing
A Vision For Stock Video Success: Daniel Hurst, VIA Films

A Vision For Stock Video Success: Daniel Hurst, VIA Films

You’ve definitely seen Daniel Hurst’s work. An early mover in high frame rate and aerial shooting for stock footage using cameras including Phantom Flex 4K and RED Weapon 8K, he’s sold over 200,000 clips through his company VIA Films. His career has been driven by trying to create shots he hasn't seen before, even if it means building a new set of skills from scratch. Daniel still sees opportunities for himself and anyone else who wants to start or grow their business in the ever-more competitive field of stock video, and offers practical advice on how you too can succeed.


Daniel Hurst
MORE
© 2020 CreativeCOW.net All Rights Reserved
[TOP]