LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

Bob Zelin Looks at The AJA GEN10

COW Library : AJA Kona - Mac : Bob Zelin : Bob Zelin Looks at The AJA GEN10
CreativeCOW presents Bob Zelin Looks at The AJA GEN10 -- AJA Kona - Mac Review


Orlando Florida USA
CreativeCOW.net. All rights reserved.


Every professional editing system has required some sort of sync generator, since the beginning of the era of television. Long ago, it was separate sync, blanking and subcarrier.

In the 1970s, composite black was created to carry all of these signals across one video wire. This use of synchronizing different pieces of video equipment has been used in every piece of professional video equipment developed ever since. We see this referred to as Genlock, External Reference, External Sync, or Reference Video.

Sync and color black generators used to cost a lot of money. But times changed, and prices got lower and lower. A little company called Horita came along, and released a very low cost color black generator - the BSG-50, and almost everyone, overnight said "I'm not gonna spend over $1000 for a black generator, I'll buy a Horita box".

And all was good - until Hi Def Video and the 23.98 frame rate cameras came along.

All of a sudden, the good old color black generator wasn't good enough anymore. People wanted to shoot, edit, and output back to tape at this new frame rate. And companies like Evertz and Tektronix came out with sync generators that would work at these new frame rates, that matched different hi def standards developed by Sony and Panasonic.

And these new sync generators - called TRI-LEVEL SYNC GENERATORS were expensive. All over $3000. And they were complicated to use. They had big manuals, rack chassis with lots of switches, and knobs, or setup control panels. Everyone was jumping into the hi def sync generator game - big names like Tektronix, Leader, Evertz, Astro Systems, Ensemble Design, Nvsion, and others. And so, people that needed tri-level sync were destined to spend over 3 grand to get a working unit.

Until April 2007.

A new hope
AJA Video shocked the world by releasing the GEN10, a multiformat tri-level sync generator, that's also a color black generator. And a color bar generator. It also generates AES digital audio tone or silence. AND it works at NTSC or PAL frame rates. AND it will do both Color Black AND tri-level Sync at the same time. All in one tiny AJA GEN10little box.

The big reason everyone jumped up and down, was its small price: $390, about 1/10th the price of any other box on the market.

So lets make this simple. You need a sync/black generator, but sometimes you need NTSC, sometimes you need PAL for those European jobs you occasionally get. And you need color bars once in a while to test your system out. And you've started getting in those Hi Def video jobs that were shot at 23.98 frame rate, and the client wants a 23.98 frame rate master on an expensive HD VTR that you'll rent. That's a lot of little boxes to buy, and you really can't justify the cost to any client.

But the AJA GEN10 solved all of these problems, and paid for itself in the first day of your first job.

In normal operation, you only need NTSC color black, and the GEN10 gives you 6 NTSC black outputs. Flip one of the tiny DIP switches on the unit, and you get 6 PAL black outputs.

Maybe your TV monitor looks weird, and you need to quickly get color bars out of this little box - flip a DIP switch, and you get 75% NTSC or PAL color bars. (No, you can't do Bars and Black at the same time - it's one or the other).

But the GEN10 is split into 2 groups - 4 BNCs on one side, and 2 BNCs on the other side. So you can have 4 BNCs putting out color black (or color bars) while the other 2 BNCs put out tri-level sync, at any frame rate you like. Or vice versa - you can have 4 BNC's putting out tri-level sync, while the other 2 are putting out black.

The typical use would be for all color black, but then you get an HD job that requires tri-level sync, because you have to lock your edit controller and HD VTR to a 720p or 1080i 23.98 frame rate (and NTSC or PAL color black can't do this!). You would flip DIP SWITCH #2 on the AJA GEN 10 to the "HD" position, and like magic, you now have your edit controller and HD VTR being fed tri-level sync, while the rest of your equipment is still getting NTSC or PAL color black. ONE LITTLE SWITCH. Want to work at 720p or 1080i - just one more little switch (it's switch # 5).

You don't even need the manual, as it's all silk screened right on the little AJA GEN10 box.

AJA GEN10 rear

The box is so flexible, that it will generate all the little variations of tri-level sync that you may be forced to work with - everything from 1080i/59.94 to 1080psf23.98 to 1080p23.98, 1080p29.97, all the 720p variations of this, and all the film rates of true 24, 30 and 60, both at 720p and 1080i. And yes folks, this product is only $390 !

But do you really need tri-level sync at all ? Well, most of my clients never work at 23.98, and so their old trusty Sigma or Horita black generators work just fine. Their VTR's do the pulldown for them to work at standard frame rates. But what if you need nothing other than NTSC black with the occasional PAL black ? You won't find ANY OTHER COMPANY making a dual standard black generator. And if you DO ever need to work at 23.98 ? For this low price, why would you ever consider any other black generator, when this does EVERYTHING.

Bottom Line
There is another great thing about this box, which is true about most of the AJA mini converters. It just plugs in and works. No setup instructions, no 60 minutes with a manual. Plug it in, and it works. Too lazy to read a .pdf file - just look at the silk screening for the DIP switches right on the back of the unit, and you are in business.

But what if you don't use Final Cut Pro? What if you don't use an AJA capture card? WHO CARES?? This is the ONLY black generator you should own, no matter what other products you have.

If you have an Avid Adrenaline, or certainly an Avid Nitris, that wants to see tri-level sync when working in 23.98 - THIS IS YOUR BOX.

Got a Blackmagic Multibridge HD or Decklink HD Extreme - THIS IS YOUR BOX.

Got 3 Sony HD cameras and a Panasonic HD-SDI switcher, and don't want to suffer the frame delay with the frame sync inputs - THE GEN10 IS YOUR BOX to genlock all of this production gear together.

No matter what you own, no matter what you do in the video business, there is no longer any reason to not own an AJA GEN10. It's as critical a piece of equipment, no less critical than a set of speakers, or a TV monitor.

Now there are plenty of people out there that are saying "I never use a black generator - I just throw my VTR to look at the Video Input as the reference signal." There are countless posts on user forums about all the problems that are generated because of this - everything from channel error conditions, to audio distortion problems, to sync errors, to VTRs not locking up.

There are always "tricks" to avoid tri-level sync, but at $390, there is no longer any excuse. Everyone can afford to have their professional video equipment locked to a stable house sync - whether they are in Europe or the US, working at standard frame rates, or 23.98, or other variations that require tri-level sync. The AJA GEN10 is just a no brainer when building a video system.


If you found this page from a direct link, please visit our forums or read other articles at CreativeCOW.net


Comments

I ran across this thread when
by Brian Roth
I ran across this thread when researching a problem I encountered with the Aja GEN10. The system in question is a new, small-ish studio that produces a live, 1 hour daily news magazine that is streamed on the net and simulcast on Cox cable in their Oklahoma markets. The majority of the plant is 1080i (with Aja FS-1 "Swiss Army Knife" boxes to input/output from/to some legacy analog equipment that was recycled from the older analog facility).

The bulk of the equipment requires tri-level sync, but there are some units that require blackburst. Hence, the GEN10 appeared to be an inexpensive answer for all "house sync" requirements.

In addition to new HD cameras on floor pedestals, we included a pair of Panasonic AW-HE100 cameras mounted from the lighting grid to supply wide shots, etc. The HE100's are self-contained "robo cams" (with remote controlled pan/tilt/zoom/focus) which come standard with analog outputs, BUT have an optional 1080i output module which we purchased for each cam.

The HE100's require blackburst sync.

When we heated up the new system earlier this week, we were stunned to see that the HE100's were vertically offset about 1/3 of a frame. IOW, the image from those cams...while horizontally synced...was almost split in half with a black bar in the "middle".

I connected my dual trace Tek scope to the outputs of the trilevel DAs and the blackburst DAs, and after some fiddling with triggering, etc. observed the vertical sync "retrace" "blanking" pulses were indeed offset between the trilevel and blackburst signals.

Thinking that we had a defective GEN10, we contacted Aja tech support. They checked with Engineering, and reported back that the trilevel and blackburst outputs ARE NOT VERTICALLY TIMED with each other!!!!

We did a quick "search and scramble" and overnighted:

DV-321 Genlockable HD/SD Sync Generator

Functionally the same as a GEN10, but with Genlock input...which I wanted from the beginning "just in case" for some odd-ball future requirement. ESE also has:

DV-319 HD/SD Sync Generator

...wiithout genlock.

Sync problem solved for a few more bucks!

I am annoyed that Aja makes NO mention of the non-timed Vertical in any of their GEN10 sales docs, nor in the tech/install manual. Live And Learn! That said, I generally like Aja products.

Bri

PS...last year I discovered that the analog outputs of the Aja FS-1 units we bought for another project had a volt or so of DC offset; that caused some problems with devices which had DC coupled inputs....."blown out" analog video. I fixed that problem by installing a low impedance 1000 microfarad capacitor in-line. Aja tech support is aware of that problem, and it may be fixed by now.

I still like Aja....
__________________
Brian Roth Technical Services
Oklahoma City, OK
http://www.BrianRoth.com
brianroth is offline Reply With Quote
Not the only generator you will ever need, though.
by Job ter Burg
Not so great if you need both PAL and 24.00p or 23.98p HD sync simultaneously. It will not do that. Check the manual, and see that, when set to PAL, this machine only does 25p/50i HD sync.
Bob Zelin Looks at The AJA GEN10
by Robin Hobart
Very cool if you're the only one working. My two problems with this box. 1. You can only output 1 tri-level signal at a time. It seems pretty common these days in production environments that someone will be working in 23.98 and someone else will be working in 59.94 and others in NTSC and even 720p. 2. It can't genlock to anything. For 1 person with a deck and a CPU this unit is pretty ideal. For anything larger than that I think you'd be painting yourself in a corner to go with this.


Related Articles / Tutorials:
AJA Kona - Mac
Cal Digit S2VRHD

Cal Digit S2VRHD

CreativeCOW's Bob Zelin tests a Cal Digit S2VRHD with a host card for a PCI-X computer, and a PCI-E computer. He used the incredible AJA Kona System Test, to evaluate the drive speeds. He was determined to 'break it.' Did he? No. He determined that...''If you want to do uncompressed HD, for a fraction of the price of an Apple Xserve RAID, or other hi end SCSI or Fibre Channel drive arrays, THIS IS YOUR BOX.'' Read the rest to find out why.

Review
Bob Zelin
AJA Kona - Mac
AJA HD10AVA Converter

AJA HD10AVA Converter

CreativeCOW's Bob Zelin discusses how to turn your HDV VTR into a professional product using the amazing AJA HD10AVA converter. It takes the analog component HD signal from your Sony or JVC HDV VTR, and converts it to an HD-SDI signal that can go right into the HD-SDI input of your capture card.

Review
Bob Zelin
AJA Kona - Mac
AJA Kona SD v2.1

AJA Kona SD v2.1

CreativeCOW leader, Marco Solorio reviews the new AJA Kona SD v. 2.1. For those seeking the latest uncompressed capture card for your Final Cut Pro system, this may be the answer you're looking for. With version 2.1 in public release, this system has unique features that other capture cards can only dream of.

Review
Marco Solorio
Recent Articles / Tutorials:
Audio Professionals
Perfecting Audio: Professional Audio Add-ons For Your iPad

Perfecting Audio: Professional Audio Add-ons For Your iPad

You're going to be amazed how easy it is to turn your iPad into a professional audio powerhouse for a variety of applications: a field recorder, a front end for controlling your DAW, MIDI keyboards and turntables for musicians and DJs, and more. Whether you're a filmmaker, a podcaster, an audio engineer, or a musician, there are surprisingly affordable and powerful options for pro audio with your iPad.

Tutorial
Adorama TV
Adobe Creative Cloud
Increase Productivity with Adobe Motion Graphics Templates

Increase Productivity with Adobe Motion Graphics Templates

Motion Graphic Templates created in either Adobe Premiere Pro or Adobe After Effects are a great way to work with clients. They help you keep a consistent look and feel while protecting your project from inadvertent changes as it passes through different hands. Here are the steps you can take to share work across teams and organizations, quickly and powerfully.

Feature
Rod Harlan
Apple Motion
Apple Motion 5: Animating Raindrops On A Window

Apple Motion 5: Animating Raindrops On A Window

Ready to have your mind blown? Longtime VFX artist, editor, software developer, and business owner Simon Ubsdell is inspired by an Andrew Kramer AE tutorial to combine Apple Motion's particles, displacements, 3D compositing, and advanced blurs to create an incredibly realistic animation of raindrops on a window. You're not going to believe how fast and fun this effect is to create, and how realistic it looks.


Simon Ubsdell
RED Digital Cinema
RED TECH: Black Shade Calibration: When, Why, and How

RED TECH: Black Shade Calibration: When, Why, and How

Learn how (as well as why and when) to run a Black Shade Calibration on your RED Digital Cinema camera to ensure clean and consistent pixel sensitivity across your entire image.


RED Digital Cinema
Panasonic Cameras
Pansonic AG-CX350 First Look: 4K, HDR, Streaming, and more

Pansonic AG-CX350 First Look: 4K, HDR, Streaming, and more

Introducing the new Panasonic AG-CX350 4K HDR 10-bit 60p camcorder, featuring Enhanced Network Capabilities for live events,, sports, and news gathering. The CX350 is equipped with the RTMP/RTSP/RTP protocol for live streaming and NewTek NDI | HX-ready for IP Production. In addition, it offers future P2 capability (via a free firmware update). At only 4.2-lbs. (body only), the CX350 is also the lightest 4K 10-bit fixed-lens camcorder in its class -- all for under $4K! Check out the details here.

Tutorial
Adorama TV
Adobe After Effects
What Are Adobe Motion Graphics Templates?

What Are Adobe Motion Graphics Templates?

A Motion Graphics Template, referred to as a MOGRT, is an animated sequence that is self-contained and can be used in Adobe Premiere Pro, Adobe Premiere Rush and Adobe After Effects, combining graphics, text, audio and video files, as well as vector or still images (including logos), to create a still or animation that can then be customized by the MOGRT user. The result is a dynamic creative tool that provides design freedom and is consistent to its users across apps and devices. Reuse, share, and even sell them!


Rod Harlan
Workflow That Plays For Keeps: How Netflix Is Protecting Stories' Futures

Workflow That Plays For Keeps: How Netflix Is Protecting Stories' Futures

If you hope to distribute your work via Netflix, you NEED to know this, but even if you're only interested in the best thinking currently available about how to preserve your own work for an unknown digital future, this is a must-read. Kylee Peña, Coordinator of Creative Technologies & Infrastructure at Netflix, and co-authors Christopher Clark and Mike Whipple share insights on the origin of Netflix archival elements, the importance of color management, and how all this comes together to preserve creative intent -- insights you can start using yourself, today.


Creative COW
MORE
© 2019 CreativeCOW.net All Rights Reserved
[TOP]