LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

Mocha v2 for After Effects

Mocha for After Effects v2
Creative COW Product Review

Brendan Coots reviews Mocha for After Effects v2 from Imagineer
Brendan Coots Brendan Coots
Splitvision Digital
San Francisco Bay area, California, USA

©2009 by Brendan Coots and CreativeCow.net. All rights are reserved.

Article Focus:
In this article, CreativeCOW leader Brendan Coots takes a look at Mocha for AE v2 and concludes that overall, Mocha for After Effects v2 is fast, friendly and cost effective, making it an excellent choice for freelancers and major studios alike.



If you’ve ever needed to track footage with the tools built in to After Effects, especially when dealing with shaky, imperfect footage or dreaded moving shots, you probably understand the flaws and limitations of pixel-based tracking all too well. I once had to track several shots for a prominent feature film using After Effects 7 (go figure) and, after a few hours, thought for sure that I was going to lose my job because I simply could not get rock-steady results on these seemingly basic film plates.

I think it’s great that Adobe sees fit to include these types of tools with their software, and at times the built-in tracking tools are the most appropriate and time saving means of getting what you need. But when you are working on professional caliber projects or find yourself dealing with challenging footage, you simply have to look elsewhere. There are a few high end tools on the market that the big visual effects houses use, but most are over-the-moon expensive, have steep learning curves and are generally off limits to commoners like you and I.

Mocha for After Effects v2 is one of the few products in this category that offers feature-film quality results at a price point well within reach of all users, hobbyists included. When you consider that Mocha also includes high-grade rotoscoping tools that can easily cut production times in half, the economics of this package start to make a lot of sense. Throw in the fact that Imagineer, the company behind Mocha, now offers Mocha for Final Cut Pro and you’ve got the makings for an affordable, studio wide solution.

There are many great tutorials available that cover the mocha workflow, but in a nutshell here’s how it works. You import your footage or frame sequence into Mocha, being careful to adjust the settings to match your source clip. Once imported, you use spline tools to draw simple mask shapes around the features you’d like to track, with little need to be precise. In fact, one of the great things about this tool is that you can move very fast without having to zero in on exact locations. Those days are over. Once your spline is laid down to roughly surround your object, you simply press the track button and Mocha handles the rest. If the particular object you are tracking begins to exit the frame, no problem - simply pause the tracker, draw a second spline around another trackable object, and resume tracking. This new spline will compliment and extend your existing spline and tracking data, making moving shots a breeze. Once the track is complete, you can copy and paste the tracking data directly into After Effects, applying it to either the source footage or a null object and you are done. It really can be that simple.

But let’s say that you also want to rotoscope an object in your shot, such as a foreground building, so that you can add isolated effects to that object in After Effects. Within Mocha you simply draw a reasonably accurate spline around the item, use the adjustment tools to soften or harden the angles of the spline, adjust the edge feathering (which can be done on a per-vertex basis, something not possible with After Effects masks), and attach the roto mask to your tracking layer. When played back, the roto mask should track perfectly with the footage, dramatically reducing the amount of manual frame-by-frame animation needed to get good results. Once you build your roto mask, it will be much, much easier to animate, requiring fewer adjustments and far fewer keyframes. Depending on the subject matter this can take mere minutes compared to the old standard of keyframing every few frames while adjusting the shape of the entire mask each time. This is an absolute dream of a workflow that will produce smiles for anyone who has rotoscoped even one shot in their lifetime. To complete the trip, Imagineer’s Shape plugin ($99) allows you to import rotoscoping data as masks directly into After Effects, rather than having to render out a matte. This is an obvious render time saver, but also affords you a second layer of control once you are back in After Effects. That said, I think many users will prefer to render mattes in Mocha just to take advantage of the extremely cool per-vertex mask feathering.

My only complaint about Mocha for AE v2 is that it did take some head-scratching to figure out how best to use some of the tools, several of which seem confusingly similar to other tools. When I set out to test some “real world footage,” that is to say imperfect focus and shot handheld, a few track tests gave me real problems but, in the end, were solved. Once I got the hang of the workflow Mocha expects you to adhere to, and began to understand how to process my less perfect footage, I found myself able to power through most tracks in under a minute flat.

The interface of Mocha for After Effects is clean, simple and laid out with speed in mind. All tools are easily accessible and arranged in a way that will feel familiar to users of Combustion, Inferno, Shake and many other visual effects apps. Working in Mocha, one begins to feel as though your next move has been anticipated and accommodated, making the whole process pleasant and, above all else, very speedy.


In terms of processing power, Mocha v2 on a common Mac Pro Quad was zippy, responsive and made short work of everything I threw at it. I pulled in several 1920x1080 DVCPROHD shots, expecting to see some level of lag from the program. It handled them with ease, and made almost laughably short work of standard definition footage. Even HD shots with multiple spline and roto tracks couldn’t bring about the kind of chugging along you might expect.

Finally, Imagineer wins the price vs. features battle hands down. Between the motion tracking/stabilizing features and the roto tools, they have put forward an extremely compelling visual effects tool that few other packages can even come close to, especially for the mere $199 price tag ($99 for upgrade). If you do any tracking or roto work, this package will pay for itself in efficiency gains the first time you put it to use, guaranteed. In future versions, I would definitely like to see the Shape plugin included as part of the main Mocha application. It is a highly valuable addition to the Mocha pipeline, but serves a fairly limited purpose which makes it hard to see the reasoning behind selling it separately.

Overall, Mocha for After Effects v2 is fast, friendly and cost effective, making it an excellent choice for freelancers and major studios alike.


Brendan Coots
Splitvision Digital
www.splitvisiondigital.com





Comments

mocha to after effects problem
by mohit khera
i am not able to copy track data from mocha to after effects i am getting sliding in my track in after effects although it is fine in mocha . i have checked the frame rate and canvas settings they all are same .
pls help
Sweet!
by Luis Cosme
Thanks for taking the time to write this review. I was wondering what this whole Mocha thing was all about and the fact that you can import directly into after effects with the mask shape variations still active throughout a certain time frame, just that alone is a great plus for me! Because I usually like to do frame by frame just to make sure it's tight! Thanks again!
Lou.
wrong details about shape plugin (?)
by Mathias Möhl
"To complete the trip, Imagineer’s Shape plugin ($99) allows you to import rotoscoping data as masks directly into After Effects,..."

That is not quite right. The data arrives as a matte generated by an effect. No AE masks are created.

"I think many users will prefer to render mattes in Mocha just to take advantage of the extremely cool per-vertex mask feathering."

You get this also with the shape plugin. So no reason to render instead.

Nice article anyway!


Related Articles / Tutorials:
Imagineer Systems
Imagineer's Mocha Version 2

Imagineer's Mocha Version 2

In this article, CreativeCOW leader Brendan Coots takes a look at Imagineer's Mocha Version 2, a standalone 2D tracking and rotoscoping tool. Read on to see what impressions Brendan's experience with this powerful and innovative tool yielded.

Review
Brendan Coots
Recent Articles / Tutorials:
Business & Marketing
Media after Millennials: A Teen’s Research on Viewing Habits

Media after Millennials: A Teen’s Research on Viewing Habits

As a fifteen year old high school sophomore, Helen Ludé has her priorities in order: varsity soccer, Snapchat and Instagram, and presenting research on Post-Millennial Media and Cinema Consumption Habits at SMPTE’s Future of Cinema Conference. Spurred on by a dinner conversation with her family (including her father, RealD’s Peter Ludé), Helen conducted a survey of her peers to uncover the viewing habits of her generation, otherwise known as Gen Z. You're going to be surprised by what she found, and deeply impressed (and a little intimidated) by this enterprising young woman.

Feature, People / Interview
Kylee Peña
TV & Movie Appreciation
Star Wars: How Much Is Too Much?

Star Wars: How Much Is Too Much?

When Disney announced that they would be making a new Star Wars movie every year for at least 10 years I was both excited and a bit skeptical. In 2012 when Lucas sold his company to Disney for $4billion, he included his outlines of Episodes VII, VIII and IX. But Disney and Co. decided to discard these stories and start over, also discarding the extended universe of comics and books that millions of SW fans had grown to love. Adding JJ Abrams to the mix was icing on the cake for SW fans who have become critical of SW. But Lawrence Kasdan was the saving grace, who wrote a script for VII that the original actors could get behind. So, how much Star Wars is too much?

Review, Editorial, Feature
Mike Cohen
Art of the Edit
Editing Marvel's Black Panther: Debbie Berman ACE

Editing Marvel's Black Panther: Debbie Berman ACE

This is an epic tale spanning two decades, three countries, 12,000 miles -- and that's just the story of Debbie Berman, ACE, starting in reality TV and indie film in South Africa, making her way to Canada and then the US to edit Marvel's Spider-man: Homecoming and, most recently, Black Panther, already one of the most popular films of all time. In this exclusive interview with Creative COW Managing Editor Kylee Peña, Debbie talks about struggling toward US citizenship, a serendipitous meeting with an ambitious young director, helping to bring representation to the big screen and pride to her home country.

People / Interview
Kylee Peña
Broadcasting
Westdoc Online interview with National Geographic Channel's VP of Development, Charlie Parsons

Westdoc Online interview with National Geographic Channel's VP of Development, Charlie Parsons

Charlie Parsons is Vice President of Development for the National Geographic Channel, responsible for developing new projects, discovering new talent and serving as one of the network’s main points of contact for the global production community. Since joining the Channel in 2010, Parsons has developed popular series “Doomsday Preppers”, “Inside Combat Rescue”, “Mars” and “One Strange Rock”, as well as the global natural history event “Earth Live”. He developed the Emmy Award winning Special “Space Dive”,as well as the Emmy Award winning feature doc “LA 92”. He also served as an Executive Producer on the network’s most watched program in history, the Emmy nominated three-hour movie event “Killing Jesus”, as well as the second and third most watched programs, “Killing Kennedy”??"also Emmy nominated for Outstanding Television Movie??"and “Killing Lincoln”, respectively.

Editorial, Feature, People / Interview
Chuck Braverman
NAB Show
Avid, Adobe, Blackmagic: Talking With Titans at NAB 2018

Avid, Adobe, Blackmagic: Talking With Titans at NAB 2018

As much as each year's NAB Show is about what's completely new, it's about hearing what's new from the industry's most enduring companies. Creative COW Contributing Editor Hillary Lewis sat down with representatives from three of the biggest titan companies in production and post -- Avid's David Colantuoni, Adobe's Laura Williams Argilla, and Blackmagic Design's Dan May -- to discuss the thought process behind their releases, what people might overlook, and their outlooks on the future of the industry.


Hillary Lewis
Adobe After Effects
Fancy Title Animations In Adobe After Effects -- FAST!

Fancy Title Animations In Adobe After Effects -- FAST!

Follow along as VFX guru Tobias Gleissenberger shows you how how to quickly create professional-looking animated text elements using the free presets that are included with Adobe After Effects, customizing them to suit your needs. Tobias will also show you how to apply masks to your text layers to have them appear from behind other elements.

Tutorial
Tobias Gleissenberger
Cinematography
Get The Shot Without Getting Shot: Adventures in Stock Video

Get The Shot Without Getting Shot: Adventures in Stock Video

Rick Ray of DVArchive has traveled the world, lived in a Buddhist monastery in Thailand, played ragtime piano for money in Australian bars, and both been arrested in Ethiopa and recruited those same police to be in his videos the very next day. In his NAB Show presentation for Adobe Stock, Rick gets specific about how to make real money in stock video following your passion around the world, what kind of equipment to choose and avoid, and yes, some advice about talking your way out of trouble.


Cow News
NAB Show
Pure Mission: NAB 2018 Highlights for Video Creatives

Pure Mission: NAB 2018 Highlights for Video Creatives

Everyone who attended NAB this year was on a mission. A mission to create the best content, a mission to deliver content to the right audience, a mission to produce great films for device and theatre viewing. We'll start by discussing some of the best solutions for some of the creative people we know - shooters, production/post folks. And there was plenty of new products, new services, new features announced at the show to get a filmmakers motor running this year. And again SuperMeet was fun, insane and informative. Shoot it, produce it, store it. Then? Sell it. It's all good and getting better!


Andy Marken
NAB Show
NAB 2018: Journey, Connections, and Life-Changing Takeaways

NAB 2018: Journey, Connections, and Life-Changing Takeaways

Many people say that the best thing about the NAB Show is the people, but then their NAB conversations are mostly about products. Thanks to a grant from the Blue Collar Post Collective, longtime Creative COW member, editor, licensed drone operator, podcaster and videographer Hannah Byars-Walker set out to build an NAB experience not around this year's gear, but around the people she'd meet who could change the course of her career, if not her life. This is her inspiring story of what happened next.


Hannah Byars-Walker
MORE
© 2018 CreativeCOW.net All Rights Reserved
[TOP]