LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

Jim Harvey reviews An Introduction to Digital Audio

COW Library : Audio Professionals : Jim Harvey : Jim Harvey reviews An Introduction to Digital Audio
Jim Harvey reviews An Introduction to Digital Audio
A Creative COW "Real World" Book Review


Jim Harvey reviews An Introduction to Digital Audio by John Watkinson

Jim Harvey Jim Harvey
JHV Digital
New York, USA

© 2002 Jim Harvey and CreativeCOW.net. All rights are reserved.


Article Focus:
Jim Harvey takes a look at An Introduction to Digital Audio by John Watkinson. ~ This book is published by Focal Press. Read why Jim says this book is a comprehensive book in every respect, but not for the faint of heart or those wishing to have guidance of a more practical nature in producing their audio.

First things first. An Introduction to Digital Audio is NOT a "How To" manual in the usual sense. Think of it more as Digital Audio 101 in a College of your choice. More a textbook and service manual than a "Buy a Sennheiser ME66 and a Beachtek adapter and you'll make nice audio". No, this is the nuts and bolts of digital audio from the ground up.

It was interesting to me that the back cover included quotes from various reviewers like HI-FI Magazine and Mobile Radio Technology. That should have been a tip off right there! When I first opened the book there was the usual "let's explore what digital audio really is" section. Most books cover that part perfunctorily and then move on to equipment choices and microphone placement. This book pulls you into the world of digital audio like Kurt Russell got pulled into the computer in TRON. We're going to see EXACTLY what happens when you record a signal on your DAT player or MiniDisc™ recorder.

Originally written in 1994, Watkinson was prescient in his statement that digital audio gives the average person tools that were either un-affordable or simply unavailable with Analog equipment. He accurately predicts the rise of digital data streams coming into our homes to be enjoyed on demand (digital cable services).

His introduction to the subject of digital audio proceeds just as any textbook would. "What is an audio signal?" Beginning with the explanation of an analog audio signal, Watkinson proceeds to point out the weakness of the analog signal and the strengths of the digital one.

Make no mistake, Watkinson knows his stuff here. He breaks down the subject into small digestible (if not somewhat dry) portions that hammer home the concept of digital audio as data (which of course it is).

Chapter 2 gets into the physics of audio and I mean PHYSICS! Any book that covers periodic and aperiodic signals along with illustrated waveforms, models of the human ear, tables and graphs of signal response, mathematical models of frequency and pressure, and contains the following sentence; "Figure 2.10 shows an uncoiled basilar membrane with the apex on the left so the usual logarithmic frequency scale can be applied.", falls WAY out of the realm of the average person's search for better audio. Each of the 11 chapters in the book cover their subjects in the same detailed manner. There are schematics and drawings galore, all of which are well laid out and to the point, but very technical.

There is very little that Watkinson misses in this book pertaining to digital equipment. He delves deep into the whole structure of digital data, with copious charts and diagrams explaining each section covered down to the last bit and byte. He covers computer systems, which as he points out are critical to digital audio. More charts and diagrams dissect the inner working of your computer until you feel as though you are reading an old assembly language text. He does manage to bring us back to the audio subject right at the point where we are scratching our heads, but again, it's DEEP. This is not a book that you are going to read at lunch hour to pick out a couple of neat tricks for that event you're shooting on the weekend. As a matter of fact, there are no tricks in this book at all, just solid theory and technical information that explains the workings of digital recording equipment.

There is no doubt that Watkinson knows his subject inside and out. His explanation of PCM (Pulse Code Modulation), Compression schemes, Networked Audio, MPEG audio compression, Sub Band and Transform coding etc. is thorough and complete. The question is, does the average person searching for good clean audio really NEED to know all this? If one is planning on a career as an audio engineer, then I would say that this book will lay the groundwork and foundation for entry into that field. It's great to know how a magnetic disc drive assembles data and then retrieves it, but this isn't something that I'm terribly interested in as I'm recording my audio. A good analogy is the computer user who doesn't need to know how memory is addressed, packets of data are stored and delivered, they just want to know that the word processor will pop up when they hit the icon for it.

If you are an information junkie, then you will certainly have more than your share of minutiae to digest in this book. Plan on spending a semester reading this over and over again and if you can retain all the information therein, you will probably know more than the engineer at your local recording studio. Whether that will make you produce better audio, however, remains to be seen. The fellow who can explain how the hard disk writes information and how the printer knows where to shoot the little spots of ink doesn't necessarily have the talent to write a good novel.

An Introduction to Digital Audio is a comprehensive book in every respect, but not for the faint of heart or those wishing to have guidance of a more practical nature in producing their audio.



I rate An Introduction to Digital Audio
(4 1/2 Cows) for aspiring Audio Engineers and don't recommend this book to those who are looking for something more practical and less "Academic".



Jim Harvey

JHV Digital



If you found this page from a direct link, please visit our forums or read other articles at CreativeCOW.net







Related Articles / Tutorials:
Audio Professionals
Perfecting Audio: AES Dublin 2019 Top Products

Perfecting Audio: AES Dublin 2019 Top Products

Join longtime audio engineer Keith Alexander for a closeup look at three of his favorite products featured at AES in Dublin 2019, including Nugen Loudness Bundle, PreSonus Studio 1 Free DAW, and the potential to build your own home studio with Smart Studio Inc.


Adorama TV
Audio Professionals
Field Recording Accessories & Mounts: Perfecting Audio

Field Recording Accessories & Mounts: Perfecting Audio

Field recording by its nature warrants good, practical kit, and longtime audio engineer Keith Alexander walks you through some of his favorite gear.


Adorama TV
Audio Professionals
Perfecting Audio: DIY Leads

Perfecting Audio: DIY Leads

Why buy leads when you can make your own? With some basic tools from vise grips to a soldering iron, longtime audio engineer Keith Alexander goes through step by step how to make a jack lead, a phono lead and XLR cables.


Adorama TV
Audio Professionals
Dialogue Cleanup Plug-ins for Video Production

Dialogue Cleanup Plug-ins for Video Production

Sometimes you really DO need to fix it in post. Longtime audio engineer Keith Alexander looks at some of the plug-ins available for video hosts including Adobe Premiere Pro and Apple Final Cut Pro X, as well as leading audio applications such as Audition, Pro Tools, and Nuendo, that will make a huge difference for video producers who need to clean up dialogue recorded with less than ideal results. There's something here for every skill level and every budget.

Tutorial
Adorama TV
Audio Professionals
Perfecting Audio: Professional Audio Add-ons For Your iPad

Perfecting Audio: Professional Audio Add-ons For Your iPad

You're going to be amazed how easy it is to turn your iPad into a professional audio powerhouse for a variety of applications: a field recorder, a front end for controlling your DAW, MIDI keyboards and turntables for musicians and DJs, and more. Whether you're a filmmaker, a podcaster, an audio engineer, or a musician, there are surprisingly affordable and powerful options for pro audio with your iPad.

Tutorial
Adorama TV
Audio Professionals
Perfecting Audio: Field Recorders

Perfecting Audio: Field Recorders

Audio professional Keith Alexander offers a personal tour through the minefield that is field recorders. The goal is to cover as many situations that may arise with the least amount of gear, and to make sure the job gets done right the first time.

Tutorial
Adorama TV
Audio Professionals
Face Vocal Band: Giving Rock a Human Voice

Face Vocal Band: Giving Rock a Human Voice

Great music transcends genre. The most memorable songs are able to cross over to different styles seamlessly. They’re timeless because the melodies and lyrics reach people no matter what kind of music they favor. That is the root of Face Vocal Band’s success. The Colorado band has been bringing audiences to their feet for seventeen years, using their uncanny ability to identify rock hits and the masterful talent to turn them into something completely new. When they take the stage, there are no guitars, no drums, no Marshall stacks??"just their voices.

Feature, People / Interview
Creative COW
Audio Professionals
2018 MPSE Award Winner John Fasal on His Passion for Sound

2018 MPSE Award Winner John Fasal on His Passion for Sound

On February 18th, the Motion Picture Sound Editors will present John Paul Fasal with its annual Career Achievement award at the 65th MPSE Golden Reel Awards. Fasal has worked in sound for more than 30 years as a sound designer and field recordist. His many credits span features, television and games, including such titles as Top Gun, Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World, Interstellar, The Dark Knight, American Sniper and this year’s box office hits Dunkirk and Coco. Fasal recently spoke with the MPSE about his career and the art of sound.

Editorial, Feature, People / Interview
Creative COW
Audio Professionals
Hearing The Handmaid's Tale: Jane Tattersall's Sound Career

Hearing The Handmaid's Tale: Jane Tattersall's Sound Career

With Emmy, BAFTA, Motion Picture Sound Editors Golden Reel, Canadian Screen, and Directors Guild of Canada Awards among many more, Jane Tattersall shares insights into a career in sound editing entering its fourth decade with two young women just beginning their own careers in the field. Their conversation begins with Jane's work on the Hulu hit series, The Handmaid's Tale.

Feature, People / Interview
Kylee Peña
Audio Professionals
Prince: Musician

Prince: Musician

One year after the sudden passing of Prince Rogers Nelson at age 57, we wanted to revisit a wonderful story too easily lost in all the tragic stories that have emerged since then: this was a man who was all about the music, 24 hours a day. Remarkable previously unseen footage of a playful Prince at an Osaka soundcheck in 1990 by Senior Vice President of Post for Chainsaw / SIM Group Steve Purcell, who worked with Prince for 6 years, sheds entirely new light on an artist you only thought you knew.

Feature, People / Interview
Tim Wilson
MORE
© 2019 CreativeCOW.net All Rights Reserved
[TOP]