Jerry Hofmann reviews Automatic Duck for FCP
Jerry Hofmann reviews Automatic Duck for FCP
: Jerry Hofmann
: Jerry Hofmann reviews Automatic Duck for FCP
A Creative COW Product Review
One of CreativeCOW's popular Final Cut Pro forum leaders, Jerry Hofmann takes a look at Automatic Composition Import FCP for Final Cut Pro users from Automatic Duck. "Im a believer. Cant get over it. Gotta have it." Jerry says these are the words that come to mind after using the new tool...
|Once in a while someone comes up a great idea for those who work day-in and-day-out creating programs with Final Cut Pro. FCP is a worthy editor by anyones standards, but its compositing capabilities are secondary to its editing workflow. Same thing can be said of any NLE. Their first and most powerful use is editing elements of picture and sound together into a sequence that tells a story of some kind, hopefully. Routinely professionals are adding sound elements and video effects that many of us use third party applications for.
The most-used application for video effects work is and has been for quite some time, Adobes After Effects. The workflow to date has been to export from your NLE the clips you want to really get that professional look out of into After Effects, a dedicated effects program. In fact there have been shorter projects entirely done in After Effects, because even though it could be used to edit projects together, the editing portion of the program was secondary to its effects capabilities. There is a tendency to forgo the use of the NLE to edit with.
Before now any programming you may have roughed out in any given shot would have to be discarded in favor of simply redoing some of it (like a fade up) in After Effects, and then exporting a rendered QuickTime file from AE, then re-importing that file into Final Cut Pro to edit it into your sequence.
The only way to save the programming you might have done in FCP was to render a QuickTime movie and import that into After Effects for further compositing. Depending on the job, you may have to export/import each clip individually. One thing that results though is that any keyframing you may have done in FCP is lost in AE. Cumbersome, tiresome, and at times took just enough of an effort, that editors might even be prone to skip the process all together just because of a lot of time and energy just to move the media files back and forth, etc
Maybe it would look a bit better with AE, but I just dont want to go through the machinations was what would go through their minds. If you wanted to do a series of shots (a sequence) to add an effect done better in After Effects, the editor becomes even less motivated. Each QuickTime Movie had to essentially be imported one at a time then re-edited in After Effects.
No more, Wes Plate and company at Automatic Duck have created pure magic. Their product will allow a Final Cut Pro editor to export an entire sequence in to Adobes product, and retain many of the keyframes created in Final Cut Pro when its opened in After Effects! Yeah, you read right, you can export an edited sequence, complete with keyframed images into After Effects, and it not only retains the keyframes (meta data in geekish) it imports all of the QuickTime movies and presents you with a composition that includes the shots edited as they were in Final Cut Pro! I told you it was magic
Automatic Duck has developed Automatic Sequence Export, an OMF export plug-in for Apples Final Cut Pro, and Automatic Composition Import FCP, an OMF import plug-in for After Effects to provide you with a powerful mechanism for combining the power of Final Cut Pro and Adobe After Effects. You will save hours of time, in turn you could save vast amounts of money as you spend your time being creative and not wasting it moving clips and rebuilding your timeline.
Automatic Sequence Export creates a representation of the Final Cut sequence and saves it in a format known as OMF (Open Media Framework), which was an initiative created and started by Avid Technology. In fact speaking of Avid, Automatic Duck has products for Avid folks too.
In addition to the timeline information, this OMF file contains links to the media for your sequence. Since both Final Cut Pro and After Effects are QuickTime-savvy applications, After Effects can use the media directly without any media conversion needed. Cool.
The OMF file is a representation of the metadata contained in the Final Cut sequence. Not everything in your timeline will translate into After Effects. Some FCP parameters dont have After Effects equivalents, other things are impossible to do programmatically as a plug-in, and other items are translatable- support just hasnt been built-in yet. It is important to work in Final Cut with the understanding that not everything translates, doing so will ensure the success of your project.
The suggested workflow is to use Final Cut to define the timing of your edit, to set up layers and mock up effects. Then use After Effects to complete the compositing, animation and effects for your sequence. Sort of an Offline effects edit in FCP, then a finishing done in AE.
When youre finished working in After Effects, render your composition to QuickTime and import the rendered file back into your Final Cut project.
Automatic Composition Import FCP will only import OMF files exported from Final Cut Pro using Automatic Sequence Export.
Its just not as important to get those effect keyframes back the other way if you really think about it
Heres a list of metadata that currently is supported for export from FCP:
So from this chart, you could see what to keyframe in Final Cut Pro, to reliably import into After Effects.
Not believing that voodoo like this was even possible, I gave it whirl. I turned this:
"Im a believer. Cant get over it. Gotta have it." These are words that come to mind
Simple, quick and saved me A LOT of work. Think if you had 50 or 100 edits to bring over, to use After Effects as your effects programmer. Cool.
True, FCP 3 can assign an editor application to a clip. What happens when you open a clip from FCP into its editor application is that clips entire media file opens in an After Effects project and you have to re-edit down only what you want to effect in After Effects. If you had added an opacity change in your timeline, it wont be there. Its better than having to do it the older way described at the top of this review, but you still have to edit down what you want to use, and you can only do this one at a time efficiently from within FCP 3. With Automatic Duck you get the whole banana AND you get the aforementioned keyframes to come across too.
Not an inexpensive plug-in particularly, but if you do this sort of work routinely, youre nuts not to purchase Automatic Ducks plug-in. Yes PLUG-IN. When you install the software, its added as a plug-in to Final Cut Pro. Shows up in the export menu from the edit menu. Another workflow feature, you dont have to open it separately from Final Cut Pro. Ive always liked watching ducks. This duck blew my mind.
-- Jerry Hofmann
|Related Articles / Tutorials:|
Videoguys Top 10 Products of 2016
As we look back at 2016, we reflect on a year that involved media consumption -- and more specifically LIVE media consumption. Increased bandwidth, improved cameras on mobile phones, and easy access to YouTube LIVE...
Production Designer Hannah Beachler on the Go Creative Show
Film and broadcast production designer Hannah Beachler talks with Go Creative Show host Ben Consoli about her work on Creed, Moonlight, and the upcoming Black Panther. Hannah Beachler is a prolific production designer with an affinity for realistic design that emphasizes emotional drama. Over the past few years, Hannahâ€™s designed some of the hottest films like, Miles Ahead, Creed, Moonlight, Beyonceâ€™s Lemonade, and the much anticipated upcoming film Black Panther. Hannah and I discuss the role of a production designer, how she collaborates with the camera department, working with director Ryan Coogler and how she finds inspiration for each of her films.
Feature, People / Interview
The Other Side of GoPro's November 30, 2016 Announcement
When GoPro announced on November 30, 2016 that they would be cutting 200 full-time jobs, closing the entertainment division, and that their president would be leaving the company, the internet came alive with those who were predicting the company's demise. But there really is another side to the story and as is often the case, the loudest voices are not always the ones with the real story. In this article, Creative COW's co-founder, Ronald Lindeboom, looks at GoPro's announcement and gives his thoughts from his point of view. As Lindeboom concludes at the end of the story, "That GoPro stumbled is not surprising to me, what is surprising is that they had such a remarkable unbroken string of success until 2016."
Editorial, Feature, Business
Microsoft Surface Studio: Does It Out-Mac the Mac?
The day before Apple was set to announce their big news for the year, Microsoft introduced their own big news and for some Mac users -- no, not all but at least some -- it seemed to recall feelings and dreams of old. This is a Microsoft that few saw coming and in their swing for the fences, they have gotten many things right. Will it be enough to plant their flag on the mountain that Apple has long been king of? We'll see.
Review, Editorial, Feature
Six Benefits of Microbudget Filmmaking - And How To Succeed!
Microscopic budgets present limitations, but can also create opportunities. Gex Williams and Brian Crone produced Ctrl+Alt+Dance for $12,000, and it made $50,000 on its first night -- which included showings on every inhabited continent, has followings in nearly every major city, translated into 9 different languages by its fans. Want to know how to achieve that kind of global engagement? Look no further than the Six Benefits of Microbudget Filmmaking.
CSNY 74: Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young's Epic Tour Revisited
Meet CSNY 74, wherein Messrs. Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young make a definitive 3-hour, 3-set, 40 song, case, supported by 8 video clips and 188 pages of written and photographic evidence, for being one of the world's very biggest and best rock and roll bands, working at the very top of their game. Creative COW's Tim Wilson explores the beautifully rendered, exceptionally satisfying experience of this historically epic tour.
Better Technology For Better Brand Engagement
Whisper Media is a Singapore-based advertising company specializing in post-production branding and product placement. With incredibly tight deadlines, and massive files to move, Whisper used Signiant Media Shuttle to reduce transfer times from 24 hours to less than 30 minutes.
Editorial, Feature, People / Interview