Jerry Hofmann reviews Automatic Duck for FCP
Jerry Hofmann reviews Automatic Duck for FCP
: Jerry Hofmann
: Jerry Hofmann reviews Automatic Duck for FCP
A Creative COW Product Review
One of CreativeCOW's popular Final Cut Pro forum leaders, Jerry Hofmann takes a look at Automatic Composition Import FCP for Final Cut Pro users from Automatic Duck. "Im a believer. Cant get over it. Gotta have it." Jerry says these are the words that come to mind after using the new tool...
|Once in a while someone comes up a great idea for those who work day-in and-day-out creating programs with Final Cut Pro. FCP is a worthy editor by anyones standards, but its compositing capabilities are secondary to its editing workflow. Same thing can be said of any NLE. Their first and most powerful use is editing elements of picture and sound together into a sequence that tells a story of some kind, hopefully. Routinely professionals are adding sound elements and video effects that many of us use third party applications for.
The most-used application for video effects work is and has been for quite some time, Adobes After Effects. The workflow to date has been to export from your NLE the clips you want to really get that professional look out of into After Effects, a dedicated effects program. In fact there have been shorter projects entirely done in After Effects, because even though it could be used to edit projects together, the editing portion of the program was secondary to its effects capabilities. There is a tendency to forgo the use of the NLE to edit with.
Before now any programming you may have roughed out in any given shot would have to be discarded in favor of simply redoing some of it (like a fade up) in After Effects, and then exporting a rendered QuickTime file from AE, then re-importing that file into Final Cut Pro to edit it into your sequence.
The only way to save the programming you might have done in FCP was to render a QuickTime movie and import that into After Effects for further compositing. Depending on the job, you may have to export/import each clip individually. One thing that results though is that any keyframing you may have done in FCP is lost in AE. Cumbersome, tiresome, and at times took just enough of an effort, that editors might even be prone to skip the process all together just because of a lot of time and energy just to move the media files back and forth, etc
Maybe it would look a bit better with AE, but I just dont want to go through the machinations was what would go through their minds. If you wanted to do a series of shots (a sequence) to add an effect done better in After Effects, the editor becomes even less motivated. Each QuickTime Movie had to essentially be imported one at a time then re-edited in After Effects.
No more, Wes Plate and company at Automatic Duck have created pure magic. Their product will allow a Final Cut Pro editor to export an entire sequence in to Adobes product, and retain many of the keyframes created in Final Cut Pro when its opened in After Effects! Yeah, you read right, you can export an edited sequence, complete with keyframed images into After Effects, and it not only retains the keyframes (meta data in geekish) it imports all of the QuickTime movies and presents you with a composition that includes the shots edited as they were in Final Cut Pro! I told you it was magic
Automatic Duck has developed Automatic Sequence Export, an OMF export plug-in for Apples Final Cut Pro, and Automatic Composition Import FCP, an OMF import plug-in for After Effects to provide you with a powerful mechanism for combining the power of Final Cut Pro and Adobe After Effects. You will save hours of time, in turn you could save vast amounts of money as you spend your time being creative and not wasting it moving clips and rebuilding your timeline.
Automatic Sequence Export creates a representation of the Final Cut sequence and saves it in a format known as OMF (Open Media Framework), which was an initiative created and started by Avid Technology. In fact speaking of Avid, Automatic Duck has products for Avid folks too.
In addition to the timeline information, this OMF file contains links to the media for your sequence. Since both Final Cut Pro and After Effects are QuickTime-savvy applications, After Effects can use the media directly without any media conversion needed. Cool.
The OMF file is a representation of the metadata contained in the Final Cut sequence. Not everything in your timeline will translate into After Effects. Some FCP parameters dont have After Effects equivalents, other things are impossible to do programmatically as a plug-in, and other items are translatable- support just hasnt been built-in yet. It is important to work in Final Cut with the understanding that not everything translates, doing so will ensure the success of your project.
The suggested workflow is to use Final Cut to define the timing of your edit, to set up layers and mock up effects. Then use After Effects to complete the compositing, animation and effects for your sequence. Sort of an Offline effects edit in FCP, then a finishing done in AE.
When youre finished working in After Effects, render your composition to QuickTime and import the rendered file back into your Final Cut project.
Automatic Composition Import FCP will only import OMF files exported from Final Cut Pro using Automatic Sequence Export.
Its just not as important to get those effect keyframes back the other way if you really think about it
Heres a list of metadata that currently is supported for export from FCP:
So from this chart, you could see what to keyframe in Final Cut Pro, to reliably import into After Effects.
Not believing that voodoo like this was even possible, I gave it whirl. I turned this:
"Im a believer. Cant get over it. Gotta have it." These are words that come to mind
Simple, quick and saved me A LOT of work. Think if you had 50 or 100 edits to bring over, to use After Effects as your effects programmer. Cool.
True, FCP 3 can assign an editor application to a clip. What happens when you open a clip from FCP into its editor application is that clips entire media file opens in an After Effects project and you have to re-edit down only what you want to effect in After Effects. If you had added an opacity change in your timeline, it wont be there. Its better than having to do it the older way described at the top of this review, but you still have to edit down what you want to use, and you can only do this one at a time efficiently from within FCP 3. With Automatic Duck you get the whole banana AND you get the aforementioned keyframes to come across too.
Not an inexpensive plug-in particularly, but if you do this sort of work routinely, youre nuts not to purchase Automatic Ducks plug-in. Yes PLUG-IN. When you install the software, its added as a plug-in to Final Cut Pro. Shows up in the export menu from the edit menu. Another workflow feature, you dont have to open it separately from Final Cut Pro. Ive always liked watching ducks. This duck blew my mind.
-- Jerry Hofmann
|Related Articles / Tutorials:|
Blackmagic Fusion 9 Advanced Keying: Fixing Problem Edges
In this advanced keying tutorial for Blackmagic Fusion, longtime VFX artist Simon Ubsdell addresses a common problem: edges too brightly lit, along with light wrap that makes compositing a challenge. Learn how to build custom keyers using Fusion's node-based compositing that solve the problem more quickly and more completely than traditional layer-based approaches.
An Open Letter to Incoming Women Freshmen in Media Programs, by Kylee PeĂ±a
A lot of so-called â€śopen lettersâ€ť on the internet address the outgoing graduates of programs. And while they should bask in the glow of congratulations and good luck because they worked hard, they earned it, and they have some serious challenges on the horizon, this letter isnâ€™t for them. Itâ€™s for you: the young woman who is leaving high school behind and beginning your first year of college in the next few weeks. Read on as Hollywood workflow supervisor and president of the Blue Collar Post Collective Kylee PeĂ±a reminds you: You have so much ahead of you!
My Illegal Internships: An Oral History, by Kylee PeĂ±a
Sure, unpaid internships arenâ€™t exclusive to post production; however, for some reason weâ€™ve collectively decided that the single biggest way to prove oneâ€™s merit is by working in some capacity for free. Itâ€™s almost as if everyone believes that because they suffered the difficulty of doing often humiliating or degrading work for free, everyone else should too. There are certainly times that personal enrichment worth the sacrifice to work for free, but employers, do you know if what you're asking interns to do for you is even legal? Follow along as Kylee gives examples from her own past internships to highlight current requirements, and lays out some suggestions to a fairer, more productive future for everyone.
An Editor's Epic Journey, by Katie Toomey
What do you do when your company folds and there's no local work? Whatever you have to. For Katie Toomey, that meant emptying her savings and heading 2000 miles west to Los Angeles, with no job in hand. The only options were make it or break it. The journey itself was difficult, but the hardest part may have been the only thing that made it all possible: asking for help. This is a truly inspiring story with tons of real-world examples of how to accomplish what feels impossible at the time.
The Evolution of Immersive Media
Immersive media is not new. Emerging technologies, such as VR and AR as we currently know them, are simply part of an evolutionary path making media more immersive. Many commentators and industry professionals became cynical after the short life-cycle of Stereoscopic 3D, and are hesitant to embrace VR, calling it another fad. International award-winning engineer, editor, colorist, VFX artist, stereoscopic 3D artist, and Head of Operations at Auckland's Department of Post, Katie Hinsen sees it differently. These technologies are simply steps within a much wider ecosystem, says Katie, where it's the combination of failures and successes that lead us towards what immersive media is to become.
The Cinematography of Get Out: Toby Oliver, ASC
Toby Oliver, ASC is the award winning cinematographer behind the lens of Jordan Peel's debut film Get Out. â€śGet Outâ€ť has received high praise from critics (99% Fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes) and moviegoers around the world for its story, acting, and cinematography. Toby shares all his lighting and lensing techniques that gave Get Out its uniquely horrifying look. He and Go Creative Show host Ben Consoli discuss the blending of horror and comedy, why Toby choose to shoot with zoom lenses, the challenges of a limited budget, and so much more.
Feature, People / Interview
Panasonic at NAB Show 2017
Panasonicâ€™s booth at NAB is going to packed with the range of goodness that showgoers have come to expect, including the Cinema VariCam Experience, a look at the control room of the future, cloud-based news production, transparent and AR displays, and much more that weâ€™ll be reporting throughout the week. Just before the show officially opened, Panasonic offered a preview of some of whatâ€™s in store for their customers, at the show and beyond, starting with a new camera system for live broadcast of 360-degree uncompressed 4K/30.
Blackmagic Design Announces DaVinci Resolve 14
Blackmagic Design today announced DaVinci Resolve 14, the biggest release in the history of the product, and an update. New features include up to 10 times performance improvement, a whole new audio post production suite with Fairlight audio built into DaVinci Resolve, and multi user collaboration tools that let multiple people edit, color and mix audio from multiple systems, all in the same project at the same time. What this means is that DaVinci Resolve 14 is like 3 high end applications in one. Customers get professional editing, color correction and the new Fairlight audio tools, with a new reduced price of $299.