These have been some interesting days since the release of Final Cut Pro X
One thing that is emerging is the PRO vs. NON PRO debate.
There seem to be three camps.
- I own and operate a facility with multiple edit suites.
- I run a professional shop that "sausage factories" out shows every day.
- I am a professional and I need a tool that fits this facitlity (which is my definition of what a professional is.)
- I don't like too much change, and generally I have a conservative approach, because I am a mission-critical shop that depends on a software tool to be exactly what I need it to be with the functionality I ask for.
For CAMP ONE pros, FCP X is a disappointment because they have bought a lot of software licenses and hardware, and have made and invested a lot of money in "facility based factory" edit enviroments. These people cannot implement FCP TEN because it is not fully functional yet, but deep down they want it to be -- they want it to work like a mature ten year old software (that FCP 7 is) in a day to day enviroment. They see a very tempting feature set in and potential in FCP TEN, but will probably have to wait to install the software.
Ironically, CAMP ONE often talks about FCP's shortcomings and have been the ones saying it had weak points that could only be addressed if the software was completely rewritten!
I will call these people EDITING professionals. This can range from the following group of creatives.
- Freelance editor -- who has to be ready to edit with anything and can't turn town jobs based on software.
- Indy film makers -- Generally a crowd who are willing to risk and embrace (probably too soon) and like to feel like the drivers of technology.
- Filmmakers -- Who wear many hats, including editing.
- Directors, Director DP's -- who are increasingly moving toward editing.
- Wedding/event Professional -- I can say without shame that I did this for two years (while in school) and it was in many ways more demanding than many professional environments. A wedding day carries a high personal expense and is emotionally charged. There is a lot of pressure to capturing and doumenting this day for people. There are excellent business models and it's a lucrative business.
Let's call this "Emerging Professionals". These fall into the following typical categories:
- I am a student.
- I am a photographer staring to shoot video.
- I am a DSLR indy film maker making music videos for free
- I am retired and always loved film
- I've edited some stuff with iMovie or Adobe Premiere, or two VCRs
Most CAMP THREE people have been professionals in other fields or are moving toward a pro or semi pro career which includes editing their own material as a part of the plan.
The CAMP ONE
people represent the least number of people in editing environments and that number is only going to get smaller as the skill set of the "editing professional" will have less and less to do with software tied to facilities and expensive workstations. CAMP TWO
represents the bulk of hardworking pros who use editing software. This group is growing. CAMP THREE
is all the potential new business.
What I am seeing and reading a lot of on the COW is that CAMP ONE
people are upset that they have to learn a new tool, upset that the new tool is not what they
wanted, they are experiencing a feeling of being disappointed and being left behind. but
, some of them at the same time are showing a lot of resentment to other professional groups for using a tool they feel they have ownership of. They feel like they are the only true editing professionals.
There have been viscious attacks on Apple in the past week from this group.
are either in the middle or defending the application and willing to wait a while to see how it evolves.
are looking for an application that works on their Mac and is as easy to use as every other Mac app.
As I was reading forums all week I thought about changing my sig file to:
You are the professional, not the software tool you choose.
But I didn't. I do think there is something to that statement though. We become very identified with the tools we use. A camera is not just a camera, an NLE is not just an NLE.
Here is they way I like to think about it:
- A pro does professional work.
- A pro does professional work, preferably with professional tools.
- A pro does not need professional tools to accomplish the task.
- A pro acts like a pro at all times.
These are the qualities of being a professional.
I've used many NLEs, many cameras, and they are all just tools in the hands of a professional -- which I call myself by these definitions.
We are in for an interesting post production ride. Let's all be pros here at the COW and let's get talking (in a constructive way) about how to use these new professional tools.
|Related Articles / Tutorials:|
Apple FCPX - Final Cut Pro X
FCPX - First Cut with the new Final Cut Pro X
David Battistella, ever willing to engage in new adventures in film and digital capture, has taken the leap toward editing his latest work with the new Final Cut Pro X. When you watch the clip from Calcio Storico Fiorentino, you will feel drawn in to the action, taste the dust in your mouth, feel the strength and violence of the game, and be washed away by the sheer power of this centuries-old sport. That's how well FCPX worked for David.
Apple FCPX - Final Cut Pro X
FCPX - Final Cut Pro Flux
As the world of post-production enters dramatic changes as of this late June 2011, with the introduction of Final Cut Pro X, Dennis Kutchera looks at the inevitable flux of new technology and what really works for the editing professional and offers some intelligent solutions for a not-yet obsolete workflow.
Apple FCPX Techniques
FCPX - Using Match EQ in Final Cut Pro X
Match EQ is a welcome addition to the audio functionality in Final Cut Pro X. Adopted from Logic Pro, this tool is as easy to use as it is powerful. While Soundtrack Pro provided a similar function, this new implementation in FCPX has more options. If you aren't obtaining your desired results using the automated match, you can delve in deeper to get the custom results you are looking for.
Tutorial, Video Tutorial
|Recent Articles / Tutorials:|
“Before I forget: don’t wear any underwear.”
Before coming to Creative COW, before his lives in product marketing and product management at Avid and Boris FX, Creative COW Editor-in-Chief Tim Wilson ran a video production company. As we also observe the 100th Anniversary of the founding of the US Parks Service, Tim recalls one one especially memorable adventure to Everglades National Park, wherein he found himself quite literally up to his armpits in alligators. He had no idea that this was going to happen when the day began. At the time, he was focused on a brand new fear: getting sliced in half by burning underwear.
Editorial, Feature, People / Interview
Art of the Edit
The Science of Editing
Sven Pape, aka @ThisGuyEdits, joins Dr. Karen Pearlman -- former President of the Australian Screen Editors Guild and a three-time nominee for Best Editing at the Australian Screen Editors Guild Annual Awards -- for a provocative look at "Editor's Thinking," a cognitive skill set that you can use to improve your screenplay before you start principal photography of your film.
Shooting MTV's Mary + Jane with Panasonic VariCam 35
To shoot the ½ hour scripted comedy series for MTV, Mary + Jane, the producers at Television 360 enlisted cinematographer Charles Papert (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Key and Peele), who found that Panasonic VariCam is a great fit for moving fast and getting great images when time and resources are scarce.
Adobe After Effects
Imagineer mocha Pro 5 Plug-In for Adobe: An In Depth Review
Imagineer mocha Pro 5 Plug-in for Adobe brings all the amazing features of the professional version of the mocha Planar Tracker directly into After Effects and Premiere Pro in the form of a plugin. In this in-depth review, After Effects tutorial guru Tobias Gleissenberger of Surfaced Studio will show you what you can do with this new plug-in, and discuss what he likes and doesn't like about the new update.
Apple Final Cut Pro X
Hawaiki Keyer 3.0 Upgrader Tutorial
After 25 years as an editor, compositor, and VFX artist, frequent Creative COW poster and tutorial author Simon Ubsdell knows what he needs from a keyer -- and knew he wasn't getting good enough results from FCPX or Motion. Discussions in COW forums led him to create the highly regarded Hawaiki Keyer for Mac users using Apple Final Cut Pro X, Apple Motion, and Adobe After Effects and Premiere Pro on Mac as well. Enthusiasm expressed by COW members for its latest release led us to ask Simon for a tour of the even more advanced Hawaiki Keyer 3.0.
All Eyes on IBC 2016 for Cameras and Lenses Galore
What’s that you say? An IBC that’s not only relevant, but downright exhilarating?
This used to not be news, of course. However, in recent years, IBC has too often become simply an opportunity for European audiences to see products already announced at NAB. In 2016, however, the focus swings sharply to Amsterdam, especially when it comes to cameras and lenses. IBC 2016 is shaping up to be one of the most dramatic trade shows for cinematographers, broadcasters, and videographers in years. Join Creative COW Editor-in-Chief Tim Wilson for a speedy overview of some of the highlights.