Fairlight + Resolve, Part 1: The DAWn of a Resolved Era
CreativeCOW presents Fairlight + Resolve, Part 1: The DAWn of a Resolved Era -- DaVinci Resolve Review


OneRiver Media
Walnut Creek, CA
©One River Media. All rights reserved.


Editor's Note: Marco Solorio is a multihyphenate extraordinaire. Since founding One River Media in 1991, he has earned a reputation as a leader in every craft he touches, including photography and cinematography, music composition and audio engineering, editing, finishing, training, and event production, with a client list that reads like a Who's Who of Silicon Valley and beyond: Apple, Dolby, Pixar, Adobe, Google, HP, Cisco, Coca-Cola, Walmart, and almost 200 more. Marco is also one of the kindest and most generous souls it's been our pleasure to encounter in a business where those traits are all too rare. I, as well as Creative COW's owners Ronald & Kathlyn Lindeboom, have known Marco since well before the founding of the COW, and I'm always delighted to cross his path. During the NAB Show 2017 it was only virtual, alas, but he and I both flipped our wigs over the announcements around the integration of the Fairlight digital audio workstation (DAW) into Blackmagic DaVinci Resolve for the combined price of only $299. His enthusiastic Instagram posts spread far and wide, and those seeds have born epic fruit in this remarkable overview of the possibilities he sees that a combined Fairlight + Resolve can offer his work. Resolve has been One River Media's finishing platform of choice since not long after Blackmagic Design acquired it in 2009, and their primary editing platform since 2015. Having been a Pro Tools user for over 20 years, and very frustrated with it for the last several of those, Marco has some strong feelings about all of this. We are delighted to share the first chapter in his findings, originally posted at the One River Media blog. We know you'll enjoy this, and look forward to hearing your thoughts in the comments below. ~Tim Wilson, Editor-in-Chief Creative COW With the National Association of Broadcasters convention in Las Vegas officially over for 2017, there was an abundant of new announcements and products throughout the show’s week-long event. But for me, nothing came close in terms of shear “wow factor” than to that of Blackmagic Design’s showing of DaVinci Resolve 14 with the inclusion of the complete Fairlight DAW. In about 4-5 month’s time, the Blackmagic/Fairlight engineers and developers integrated the Fairlight DAW right into DaVinci Resolve, complete with hardware interfacing with audio I/O and modular mixing control surface integration. Despite the fact the team is still hard at work to complete all the planned features, this was an amazing feat to undertake. I honestly don’t know how these people were able to do this in such a short amount of time (I guess they don’t like sleep). The running joke at the show I kept hearing from people was that Blackmagic/Fairlight was able to build this NLE/DAW solution in 6 months, doing more than [insert any other NLE/audio platform] has done in the last 6 years. I unintentionally spent 95% of a full day 1 at NAB at the Blackmagic booth… this is the reason why. While at NAB, I had the opportunity to spend an enormous amount of time with the Blackmagic/Fairlight engineers and developers to dig deep with the new advancements as well as play with the Fairlight mixing consoles to really get a feel for how this all works together. In short, it exceeded all my expectations. The new Fairlight + DaVinci Resolve integration is the most exciting thing I've seen come along in audio as a professional ProTools user for 20 years and as an audio engineer for almost 30. ONCE FRUSTRATED, NOW ELATED So what’s the big deal? Why the excitement? To answer that, let me briefly explain a little background. I’ve been a ProTools user for roughly 20 years now. Over that time, I’ve invested a LOT of money in building and expanding our ProTools equipment in our audio control room and recording studio of the years. Part of that investment includes a 40-channel ProControl mixing console with Edit Pack (surround sound support) that Avid hasn’t supported since ProTools 10 (ProTools is up to version 12.7 as of this writing). In other words, Avid refuses to allow their older control surfaces to work with ProTools 11 or 12 (remember, there is no audio processing in these control surfaces at all) in hopes of forcing their longtime legacy users like me into buying into their new hardware, specifically the high-dollar S3 control surface (singular, non-expandable unit) and S6 modular control surface lineup as the top offerings from Avid. Other options include the dated and non-expandable C|24 console and the small but limited Artist Series that include the Artist Mix, Artist Control, and the newer ProTools Dock that requires an addition Apple iPad purchase). The S3 and S6 options are ludicrous to me since (A) my old control surface hardware works perfectly for my needs and (B) other companies have long supported their older control surface hardware with modern software (e.g., a 15-year old DaVinci panel can work under today’s Resolve under Linux and the original Fairlight control surfaces from decades ago still work with today’s Fairlight software). I’ve been more than willing to upgrade to Avid’s newer PCIe hardware and I/O hardware, but the buck stops here with the need to replace my entire surround sound mixing console that is otherwise perfectly functional. Our 40-channel mixing console in our Audio Control Room is perfectly functional and supports 5.1 surround sound mixing… but is no longer supported by AVID and deemed E.O.L. after ProTools version 10 (currently at version 12.7). For the last 2 to 3 years I’ve been at a loss with finding a solution to this problem. My hope was to (A) do away with ProTools altogether, (B) use alternative professional DAW software that was fast and high-end, (C) and was completely modular so that I could grow into a larger control surface mixing console as needed. And let’s be honest… prior to version 14, Resolve’s audio integration was decently good but it definitely wasn’t “DAW worthy”, as noted in my extensive Resolve article last October.

THE FAIRLIGHT FOUNDATION But the solution is finally here and it’s DaVinci Resolve’s integration of Fairlight. At the core, Fairlight is intertwined within DaVinci Resolve. This is a key point. Rather than being a stand-alone application, Fairlight works exactly the same way the NLE portion within Resolve works, in that you can edit, color grade, and mix your audio non-linearly without the need for dealing with cumbersome XML/AAF translation project files between programs and round-tripping. While I’m building an editorial rough cut of a video, I can also start tweaking the dialog mix, while also building the color grade, ALL AT THE SAME TIME. I never have to leave the Resolve ecosphere. This is huge. Likewise, any audio parameters that are made in either the Edit page or Audio page are completely mirrored in both pages. So for example, lets say I’m in the Edit page working on an audio clip and I adjust the EQ, the compressor, add a VST plugin like RX6 De-noiser, and then adjust the parameters and values for those audio parameters. I can then go into the Audio/Fairlight page and all of those audio plugins I added in the Edit page are now exactly mirrored to their exact values between the Edit and Audio pages. The biggest difference of course is when you’re in the Fairlight page, you have much more control, features, and visual feedback of your audio edits. To go a step further (and this blows my freaking mind), Resolve’s new collaboration features with “timeline comparison” is the holy grail of workflow versioning. In a nutshell, it allows multiple AND singular users to see what changes have been made in the project timeline between users/sequences, whether it’s audio + video + grading, video only, grading only, audio only, or whatever combination. So between video editing, color grading, and audio mixing, you have a graphically supported breakdown of how the build of the project is coming along. Avid Media Composer + ProTools doesn’t do this, Adobe Premiere + Lumetry + Audition doesn’t do this, nor does Apple FCPX + Logic do this. Blackmagic has built a new paradigm in modern post-production workflow in Resolve that others can only look up to at this point. Truly revolutionary. The collaboration feature in Resolve’s editing timeline is a first for any post-production software suite, offering unparalleled workflow control and efficiency between multiple and singular users alike. RESOLVE'S MASSIVE IMPROVEMENTS DaVinci Resolve 14 has countless other new features as well, including major performance gains (much smoother UI interaction and responsiveness with greater support for slower/older computers due in part to fully exploiting CPU+GPU resources and smarter base code, with Blackmagic stating a very convincible “10X” gain), facial recognition based enhancements, noise reduction speed improvements, updated motion tracking (catapulting off their already amazing tracker), and countless other features and enhancement that clearly sets Resolve 14 apart. But to kick off the new version 14 update, the new $299 price tag for the full Resolve Studio software is another shocker (was $995). The USB dongle is no longer needed but can be used in place of the new serial number registration method. I’ve never been a fan of “renting” software as a monthly fee, so the flat $299 cost is a HUGE welcome to users and ultimately costs way less than other monthly solutions. In fact, Blackmagic Design still has yet to charge users an upgrade fee for any major software release! From version 9 (when Blackmagic acquired DaVinci) to the new 14, not a penny has been charged for upgrades! Blows my mind. Oh and not to forget… the free version of Resolve completely includes Fairlight. Yes, a high-end professional DAW for FREE. The reDAWn of Fairlight For me, the biggest addition to Resolve 14 is the inclusion of the complete Fairlight DAW solution itself. With decades of audio know-how, Fairlight is an audio post-production giant, to say the least. Although Fairlight has been a competitor to ProTools forever, I’m quite certain this will be the first time ProTools has serious grounds for concern from a broader market perspective… especially when you consider the fully capable free version of Resolve includes the Fairlight DAW. Running the beta version of Resolve 14 through its paces, I tested Fairlight’s functionality by using the timeline from our 2-hour feature film, “10/10ths”. Click the image to view it larger. As for audio plugins, VST is fully supported (as it has been for Resolve prior to version 14), so my favorite audio plugins from giants like Waves, Izotpoe, Sonnox, Lexicon, Brainworx, and others are compatible (I’ve been loving Izotope’s RX series within Resolve 12 and 12.5). Automation of plugin settings over time is also supported. You can stack six instances of plugins per track or clip. Let me be clear; BOTH track-based plugins AND clip-based plugins are fully supported. Not having this in ProTools has been one of the pinnacle issues for me for many years. Even with ProTools’ latest clip-based plugin support (AKA, “clip effects”) it’s limited to Avid’s basic EQ and compression channel strip plugin (which means none of your favorite plugins can be used) and is only available in the much more costly ProTools HD version. This lack of much requested flexibility in ProTools boggles my mind. But we’re talking Fairlight and DaVinci Resolve here, so now you’re free to use plugins across tracks AND clips. FAIRLIGHT IS HARDWARE TOO It’s the Fairlight hardware that really has me excited. To start things off, the Fairlight PCIe accelerator card allows for 1000 real-time playback tracks with extremely low latency (sub-millisecond). You can also record 96 tracks while concurrently playing 128 tracks at the same time (bonkers!). At the core is a Fairlight 1-RU I/O box with programmable interfacing with the Fairlight DAW (assignable digital patch bay within Fairlight itself) and includes a multitude of digital and analog I/O (more on this in a forthcoming article in this series). Need surround sound support beyond the basic 5.1 or 7.1 matrix? How about Dolby® Atmos™, DTS® MDA, and NHK’s 22.2 for some surround sound love? Fully supported in Fairlight. The Fairlight hardware sets itself apart from software-only based DAWs by an immeasurable factor. The Fairlight control surface mixing console is where it’s at though. Because the layout is both horizontally AND vertically modular, you can truly build a mixing console to fit your needs from small to truly massive. I’ve been begging for such modular integration for the last few years now and it’s finally a reality for us. If you REALLY want to go big, a total of 96 channel strips can be built together (9 Fairlight bays, including the master section), which would roughly be a 15-foot wide mixing desk! Holy moly!!! These modules are easily connected together by basic Ethernet cables. It really doesn’t get much simpler than that. This single Fairlight PCIe accelerator card allows the DAW to immediately grow into a 1000-track, low latency powerhouse. The existing Fairlight mixing console frames support 19” rack mount devices (with backend vertical depth, aka, “buckets”), so if you save room for empty banks, you could then include additional outboard gear within the console as well, like your favorite mic pres, compressors, EQ, mastering tools, etc. I like the idea of adding 500 Series Neve mic pre modules, specifically for tracking. This 5-bay, 48-strip Fairlight console can be maxed out to a 9-bay, 96-strip console in case this isn't big enough for your needs. The dedicated LCD screen for each Fairlight 12-strip fader bank can display a multitude of feedback, from a basic overview of the 12 channel strip settings (shown) to highly detailed parameters of a single-selected channel strip focus. Even VST plugins settings can be viewed/controlled here. (More on this in the follow-up article). INDEPENDENTS VS. FACILITIES So what does this all mean for boutique studios or “all-in-one” freelancers? Well quite simply, for users that edit, grade, and mix for their clients, Resolve 14 is the most advanced workflow system there has ever been. Not having to bounce between separate applications using interchange files (XML, AAF, etc.) is a dream come true, especially if you tend to (as I do) like to sculpt the audio mix during the video edit, including audio plugins and such. There is absolutely never a chance of losing interchange data for fade, level, plugin, surround panning, or anything else since everything lives under one efficient ecosystem in Resolve. Like a kid in a candy store. Playing with the master section of the Fairlight console. The fact I was doing this in DaVinci Resolve was blowing my mind to no end. What about larger facilities that incorporate a solid foundation in their existing workflows? This scenario becomes a bit more complex and I wager some facilities will be slower to adopt change than others. But the vast majority of full-service post-productions facilities already incorporate DaVinci Resolve as part of their finishing services, so that pipeline is already solid. While bigger facilities have traditionally used Avid or Premiere as their primary NLE, I’m seeing slow changes in this, as Resolve’s NLE has become more and more robust with each major update. I think the slowest adoption for larger facilities will be on the Fairlight side of things because many of these larger facilities currently using expensive Avid S6 control surfaces with ProTools (and for the record, I think the S6 is an absolutely amazing control surface, just ridiculously expensive). In many cases, these facilities have invested, literally, hundreds of thousands of dollars in hardware, software, integration, and support. But as technology changes, workflow demands increase, and service plans end, there will come a point (maybe months, maybe years from now), when even these large facilities will have to look at what makes most sense for their creative, technical, and deadline needs in their audio post-production workflow. There will always be die-hard ProTools users (I was one of them for about 20 years, up until about a year or so ago), but Fairlight just got a major technology boost that is extremely hard to ignore. And let’s not forget… there’s already a large base of existing die-hard Fairlight users as well (I personally know several of them!) that go decades back, which brings me to my next point: On the flip side, there will be large post facilities that will integrate the Fairlight/Resolve solution immediately, placing it squarely in their “A” Audio Control Room. The speed gains, the efficiency gains, and the error-free-interchange between editing + grading + mixing is just too paramount to not incorporate, especially when you can literally SEE the changes between users and their timeline updates. This is a major paradigm shift in the industry that no other post-production “suite” of software has ever been able to pull off, even from the “Three A’s”: Avid, Apple, and Adobe. The Fairlight’s master section is a thing of beauty. The LCD screen can display a multitude of focused settings, while all of the keyboard buttons below it change, depending on the current screen. Rather than using costly independent OLED buttons, the keyboard (with clear buttons) sits on top of a single LCD screen. BRILLIANT. The master monitoring section is simple but effective, from mono to surround with multiple monitoring outputs. Additional monitor/talkback buttons are also located in the main section (near the jog shuttle control). Fairlight's channel strip controls are straightforward and easy to use. Each strip has its own dedicated color LCD screen to show various information and channel name/number. This is all great. So how much does the Fairlight hardware cost? Unfortunately I don’t have an answer for all of that just yet, since Blackmagic is still ironing out some of those details. Expect an answer in the next couple of months on finalization of hardware pricing (but like all Blackmagic acquisitions, it's highly likely prices will be much lower than previous costs). Until then, I've come up with a basic matrix of comparative costs and don't forget you can download the public beta of Resolve/Fairlight to play with the new features in the Free or Studio versions. As of this writing, Resolve 14 is still in public beta, so keep that in mind when testing. The Resolve/Fairlight development teams are pushing through to add all of the remaining Fairlight technologies into Resolve and like anything software related, but that does take time. At least the public beta gives you insight into how the cohabitation between Resolve and Fairlight works together. Comparative Pricing At A Glance (Prices as of this writing in U.S. Dollars)
Blackmagic Design DaVinci Resolve / Fairlight Options
FREEResolve
$299Resolve Studio
$995*Fairlight PCIe Accelerator card
$2295*Fairlight 1RU Digital/Analog Audio Interface box
FREEResolve/Fairlight Support
AVID ProTools Options
$24.92ProTools (Monthly Subscription, upgrades included, no hardware)
$299ProTools (Annual License, upgrades included, no hardware)
$599ProTools (Perpetual License, upgrades NOT included, no hardware)
$2499ProTools HD (Perpetual License, no hardware)
$2999ProTools HD (Perpetual license w/ PCIe Native card, no audio I/O hardware)
$4999ProTools HD (Perpetual license w/ PCIe HDX core card, no audio I/O hardware)
$1899ProTools HD Software Upgrade (From previous version)
$999ProTools HD (Reinstatement Plan up to 1 year)
$399ProTools HD (Annual Support Renewal Plan)
$1999AVID HD I/O PRE
$1999AVID HD I/O 16×16 Digital
$2995AVID HD I/O OMNI
$3499AVID HD I/O 8x8x8 Digital/Analog
$4499AVID HD I/O 16×16 Analog
$4495AVID HD MADI
*Note: Fairlight hardware prices subject to change upon official release (likely to be same or lower). Overpriced and confusing on the ProTools software end? Yeah, I think so too. I’m tired of this old model of pricing and I know many audio people that share the same frustration. And I haven't even got into the numbers of control surface costs (that'll come in a forthcoming article in this series). On the Resolve/Fairlight end of things, it's extremely straightforward with no annual plans to deal with. And as I've mentioned, there hasn't been an upgrade charge for any new version of Resolve since Blackmagic acquired it in 2009. So from Resolve Studio version 9 to 14, upgrades and updates have all been 100% FREE. There's no promise this trend will continue with Blackmagic Design, but as it stands, for those of us that have been Resolve Studio users for the last 5 years have had to pay zero dollars on updates. I definitely can't say the same for ProTools! And the crazy part is that Resolve Free is still a very viable and capable solution for using Fairlight strictly as a DAW solution. CONCLUSION In a nutshell, I’m joyfully ecstatic about Resolve’s integration of Fairlight and its modular-based hardware integration. It’s going to save so much time in our post-production workflow process, especially when clients ask for that “small” change that affects the edit/grade/mix of the project. Dealing with “picture-lock” will be a thing of the past in regards to not having the ability to change an edit when we’re at the 5.1 surround mix phase. There’s countless times I want to “fix” a clip in the early edit phase (whether color-based or audio-based) and now I don’t have to wait until the finishing stage to do so; it can all be done while I’m cutting the edit so the client doesn’t have to see/hear some of the blatant “rough stuff” on the first go-around of an edit review. DaVinci Resolve has been our color grading tool for about seven years now (shortly after Blackmagic acquired it in 2009). Likewise, Resolve has been our primary NLE system for about 1.5 years now (since version 12 beta). And after 20 years of professional ProTools use, Fairlight in Resolve will now be our primary DAW system. And while the Fairlight integration is still in its infancy during this beta stage, I'm highly optimistic with the promise of a matured system… just look at what has evolved from Resolve 9 to 14 since Blackmagic Design has developed it! As we continue with the Fairlight integration process in the coming weeks/months (as Blackmagic completes the entirety of Fairlight features and hardware manufacturing), I’ll be posting updates to this process, as well as how we’re using the Fairlight system in our projects. To say I’m excited about this is a huge understatement! Congratulations to Blackmagic and Fairlight for all the hard work. To me, it definitely looks to be a winner! The Fairlight control surface is straightforward and easy to use while increasing speed and controllability in the mixing session. Top Fairlight Highlights: Our thanks again to Marco for allowing us to share this here! Please check out the rest of Marco's industry coverage at the One River Media blog, and look for Marco on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook, too.