LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See

COW Library : TV & Movie Appreciation : Tim Wilson : The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See
CreativeCOW presents The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See -- TV & Movie Appreciation Editorial
Oahu Hawaii USA All rights reserved.

When Peter O'Toole passed away in 2013 at age 81, he still seemed too young to leave us. Between the time he spent on stage (primarily in plays by Shakespeare and Samuel Beckett) and breaks for his poor health, we simply didn't see him in enough movies.

His performance in Lawrence of Arabia was so overwhelming, and the movie itself so very nearly perfect, that it's easy to forget that Peter's resume is full of performances at least that strong – even if the movies themselves were only occasionally even close to Lawrence's league.

In fact, he was nominated for eight Oscars, and most people can remember two of them. The other besides Lawrence, My Favorite Year, was a charming trifle, but little more I think. The nomination was more based on the pleasure of him playing a part based on someone not unlike his younger self, played both slyly and exuberantly.)

For that matter, some of Peter's best work was never nominated for Oscars at all. He of course never won, making him the actor with the most nominations to still fall short. His performances rarely did, though. Here are five movies to set the record straight: Peter O'Toole brought us more than Lawrence. There was never anyone like him, and here are some examples of why there never will be.


The Ruling Class poster Peter O'Toole

Barely remembered now, The Ruling Class earned O'Toole his fifth Oscar nomination in 10 years. The first half of the story is a charming comedy.

Jack Arnold Alexander Tancred Gurney is a paranoid schizophrenic who accidentally becomes the 14th Earl of Gurney. His delusion that he's Jesus Christ is a problem for his membership in the House of Lords, so his family conspires to get him out of the way. O'Toole is both sweet and charismatic as the "God of Love," gently dismissing naysayers with open arms, and a beatific expression lit from within. Nobody was ever as luminous as O'Toole was in roles like this.

The second half turns very, very dark. Attempts to "cure" him work in one way. Jack is no longer "Jesus, the God of Love," but now, Jack The Ripper – a vile, murderous misogynist who has cultivated the skill of appearing civilized when needed for his public political life.

Jack eventually makes a ranting, psychotic speech extolling corporal and capital punishment on the floor of the House of Lords, to rioutous applause. So there it is: preaching love, he's seen as a madman. Ranting hate, he becomes a political hero.

Parts of the satire seem dated, and were pretty heavy-handed for the time. The priesthood, the debauched peerage, social norms – all of this and more comes under fire, and in most ways, falling short of the standards of British satire from decades earlier. Yet even as the heavy-handedness feels dated, it also feels far more relevant than when I first saw it 30 years ago.

Here's the thing though: it gets DARK. REALLY DARK. One of the blackest of black comedies I've ever seen. I can't imagine the viewer who won't come out of it disturbed, and maybe a little sickened. But my my my, this is one of the most powerful performances in the history of movies. O'Toole is so persuasively light and dark, entirely organically integrating both, that it's almost impossible to believe how naturally he reveals both sides of Jack's character.

Apparently effortless and overwhelmingly powerful at the same time, and absolutely indisispensible. If you want to see what bravura acting is all about, start here.

The unfortunate news is that this one won't be easy to come by. The 2001 Criterion DVD was a limited edition (100,000 copies) and all-but-vanished. It's worth hunting down though, if for no other reason than a nifty commentary track from O'Toole, director Peter Medak, and writer Peter Barnes, who adapted the screenplay from his own novel. The addition of Medak's home movies from the set aren't essential, but they're fun. Worth hunting down, though.

"The Ruling Class" Trailer


I actually came within a hairsbreadth of putting this in my top slot for must-see O'Toole performances. It's breathtaking, in a movie that should be much better known than it is today. O'Toole won his sixth Best Actor Oscar nom for this one, which also won nominations for director Richard Rush and his adapted screenplay, co-written with Lawrence Marcus.

This thing is insane, as is the making of the movie. The first 8 years of its journey were tangled up in financial disaster and artistic head-butting. As Rush observed later, "They couldn't figure out if it was a comedy, a drama, if it was a social satire, if it was an action adventure...and, of course, the answer was, 'Yes, it's all those things'. But that isn't a satisfactory answer to a studio executive."

O'Toole felt especially strongly about the film's potential, reportedly telling Rush, "If you don't give me the part, I will kill you." Watching him in it, it's not hard to believe. It's another of his most complex, nuanced performances: charming, abusive, generous, visionary, manipulative, benevolent, cruel – sometimes all of these in a single line.

What's especially fun for movie-philes (even more than cine-philes) is the playful look at moviemaking with O'Toole as Eli Cross, a director with a God complex. God? Cross? GET IT? That's about as subtle as the movie gets – to the extent that you can figure out what's going on at all. The movie plays with reality for the viewer, leaving us constantly wondering what we're looking at. The actors in the movie being made feel the same thing we do as we're watching: "Is he trying to get a realistically terrified performance out of me, or is he is REALLY trying to kill me?" The actor is never clear on this, and neither are we.

Clip from "The Stunt Man"

It's so hard to find your footing, that I understand why it took another two years after it was made to find a distribution deal. Response was divided among critics and audiences, with a recent thread on the IMDb discussion board with the subject, "Can anyone explain this movie?"

Here's the answer in eight words: Peter O'Toole at the very top of his game. Four more words: filmmaking without a net.

Not always pleasant, but I really do recommend this one extremely highly.

Fortunately, it's easier to find than The Ruling Class. Amazon Instant has it, and it's available on Blu-ray and DVD. Those disk versions are the ones to go with if you can, featuring another nifty commentary by O'Toole – who observes "This movie wasn't released – it ESCAPED" – along with director/author Rush, actors Steve Railsback (playing the stunt man) and Alex Rocco in a variety of features and commentaries.

The original 2-disk DVD set also includes a separate feature, THE SINISTER SAGA OF MAKING 'THE STUNT MAN.' What a mess that thing is. Very informative, but turn of the century "edgy" DV filmmaking at its absolute worst. Still, you can get it for under $3 used, and if you like The Stunt Man as much as I think you will, you'll enjoy this making-of feature. Enough. Once.


In which Peter O'Toole twice plays England's King Henry II, is nominated for an Oscar both times, and loses both times.

Not that they're the same movie by any means, or even much related. I much prefer the first, which puts O'Toole toe to toe with Richard Burton at his most gorgeous. The two were both nominated for Best Actor, much preferable to the contemporary dodge of artificially pushing one of them into the supporting role – where in fact, John Gielgud had been nominated for this film as well.

Anne V. Coates was nominated for an Oscar for her editing, having won for Lawrence of Arabia. The total of 10 nominations for Becket included Best Picture, Best Director, and "Best Cinematography, Color" (except for 1957, color and B&W were separate categories from 1939-1967), with a win for Best Adapted Screenplay.

The deeply passionate, conflicted relationship that Burton and O'Toole portray was rendered as unambiguously platonic, no winks whatsoever, and if we could, pretty please, use the word "homoerotic" entirely devoid of literally sexual connotation – IT'S NOT ABOUT SEX – an exceptionally powerful and profoundly moving example of it is here on full display.

The shift in their relationship as Becket chooses God over king feels deeply personal. O'Toole's howls at what he sees as his friend's betrayal reflect the almost unbearable heat that they both generated in every direction, toward each other and toward us watching them.

This is also a reminder of the days when actors themselves provided the spectacle, bursting out of the Panavision frame. You really don't want to miss this one.

Hey, and a funky historical footnote: O'Toole dropped out of the original stage production of Becket to star in Lawrence of Arabia!

A LION IN WINTER takes place in a single year contained in Becket's epic sweep. It's a bit harder to watch, even though Katherine Hepburn won an Oscar for her portrayal of Eleanor of Acquitane (in the only tie for Best Actress in Oscar history, with Barbara Streisand for Funny Girl), more than holding her own against the once again Oscar-nominated O'Toole. The screwball-style interactions between them – rapid fire, sotto voce – are anything but comic though. They're kind of mean, with Eleanor definitely taking the worst of it.

It's not technically in my overall Peter O'Toole top 5, as it's really more of a great Katherine Hepburn movie than a great Peter O'Toole movie, but I can't think of Becket without thinking of this. Still, it's an outstanding movie, winning 3 of its 7 Oscar nominations (Actress, Adapted Screenplay and Score), and if the notion of these two titanic talents going full-tilt at each other sounds appealing, you won't be disappointed.


"Goodbye Mr. Chips" Trailer


An almost perfect remake, for all the right reasons: take a beloved black & white picture from 30 years earlier that was feeling more dated than it deserved, update it with the beloved Peter O'Toole still ascending, make it widescreen, and add indelible, musical moments courtesy of the luminous Petula Clark.

Honestly, it feels a little odd to be adding yet another Oscar-nominated role to the list of his overlooked performances (his 4th of 8), but dagnabbit, I don't hear people talking about this one as much as it deserves. Critical reaction to the movie as a whole was mixed at the time, but not the praise for these two actors, who are both fantastic. (Critics might have been somewhat divided, but audiences weren't divided at all: universal love for both the actors and the picture.)

O'Toole is more than the title character. He's the way we experience the changing world of English boarding schools from the time between the World Wars through the late 60s – but that comes nowhere close to doing justice to the wondrousness of his performance.

The other movies on this list see O'Toole exploding out of the screen with the overwhelming scale of his performance, but he breaks through this time through the quiet intimacy of his performance. It's so deeply felt, so completely human, so utterly HUMANE, that if you're not moved to tears at least twice during the picture, I don't want to hear about it.


What's New Pussycat? is a complete mess, verging on disaster, but noteworthy for a number of reasons.

For some people, the only reason you'll need to watch is that it's Woody Allen's debut as a screenwriter and an actor. Admittedly, that may also be reason enough to avoid it for others.

Even though O'Toole is theoretically the lead (you can tell, because every woman in the picture is in love with him), Peter Sellers shares top billing as O'Toole's psychiatrist, who happens to be stalking one of his patients, who happens to be in love with O'Toole's character. Even though it's intended as a light comedy, a swinging sixties take on French farce – Everybody winds up in the same country inn! On the same weekend! And none of them know it! – it's kind of creepy.

The energy cannot be denied, though. Sellers was in manic mode, famously drugged up offscreen, and turned up to 11. One can only imagine that O'Toole and any number of bottles of brown liquid were finding their way to each other as well. Things were so out of hand that the theatrical trailer opens with two bloopers!

Oh, and Ursula Andress accidentally parachutes into Peter O'Toole's convertible.

Plus the Oscar-nominated title track by Burt Bachrach and Hal David, with Tom Jones singing the snot out of it. Plus the poster art by Frank Frazetta.

And yes, Peter O'Toole, neither bellowing nor intimate, just blasting his way through an iconic performance that became an archetype, and later, a caricature. This kind of self-indulgent, big-budget disposability, created and delivered with little regard for the audience, is the kind of thing that eventually sent the entire decade of major studio filmmaking off the rails, and didn't do anything at all for the health of its leads...but if you can get past the sexism, it's a wild ride. Frankly, it's remarkable that anyone survived the making of it. That O'Toole still manages to somehow tower over the madness is almost stupefying.

I'm adding LORD JIM as a bonus because it's a hot mess of another sort: an Ultra Panavision 70 epic, following a fallen hero through redemption in the waning days of the British Empire. This bears some similarities to Lawrence, in that we spend a lot of time staring into the pain expressed in O'Toole's glowing blue eyes.

Wikipedia reports without citation that, despite it undeniably falling flat, O'Toole later said that Lord Jim was the finest role he did. ABC's obituary quotes him saying, "[My performance] was a mistake and I made the mistake because I was conservative and played safe." There's an extent to which the truth lies somewhere between, and another extent to which both are entirely, 100% true.

When I said at the beginning of this article that we'll never see another one like him, consider this: he made Lawrence, Becket, Lord Jim and What's New, Pussycat? IN A ROW, between 1962 and 1965, and still managed to take a little time off to play Hamlet, under Laurence Olivier's direction in the Royal National Theatre in 1963.


There are many other even more deeply hidden gems in Peter O'Toole's filmography, but add these five to the two that most O'Toole fans have surely seen (Lawrence of Arabia and My Favorite Year), and you'll have witnessed more magic, more power, and more sheer delight in the power of performance than most actors delivered in careers with 10 or 15 times as many pictures.

ACADEMY AWARDS® and OSCAR® are the registered trademarks and service marks of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.


Re: The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See
by MIke Janowski
Thank you for including "The Stunt Man" in this list...I've been bending anyone's ear who cares to listen about that film ever since I saw it on Cinemax back in the early 80s..."Eli and his killer crane", indeed!

The scene where, in order to get the performance he wants from his lead actress, he lets slip that her parents "accidentally" saw rushes from her nude scene is particularly telling and intense. Great post!
Re: The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See
by Claude Rozsa
There is also Murphy's war and the night of the generals; in the second one he is astounding in the role of the psychopath German general....
Claude (Paris France)
Re: Article: The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See
by Herb Sevush
You are way too dismissive of both "My Favorite Year" and "The Lion in Winter", both of which I prefer to the heavy handed self-importance of "the Ruling Class." However you are quite correct that O'Toole was fabulous in all of them, and pretty much everything else he ever did. I would also add to your list the very light trifle of a comedic ghost story in Ireland that was "High Spirits" and also mention his wonderful role in the TV mini-series "Masada."

Herb Sevush
Zebra Productions
nothin' attached to nothin'
"Deciding the spine is the process of editing" F. Bieberkopf
@Herb Sevush
by Tim Wilson
I commented at the beginning that not all the MOVIES were as good as Peter's performance in them, and I agree that The Ruling Class fits the bill. Like a lot of satires of the day, it picked pretty easy targets (Self-appointed messiahs might be unhinged? You don't say! Ruling class insensitive to the lower classes? Tell me no!).

But in fairness to myself, I did say that the second half in particular would be hard to watch for some people, including me. Even bailing at the end of part 1 more than makes my case though: I think one of the great performances of the age by anyone.

Along those lines, note that I called What's New Pussycat creepy, and an example of what sent the studio system off the rails in the 60s -- but O'Toole's performance is still a must-see. I think I was pretty even handed with all of these.

I also called Lion in Winter outstanding, which is hardly dismissing it...except I really do think it's a better Katherine Hepburn movie than a Peter O'Toole movie, and I really do find her treatment truly unpleasant, by both the filmmakers and the characters -- and she more than earned her Oscar.

But I stand by my assessment re: Becket, that that's by far the better movie. Lion also has going for it that more O'Toole fans have seen it over time -- again, I think at least as much for Hepburn -- so certainly to the extent that I'm pimping lesser-trafficked titles, all the more reason to give the nod to O'Toole and Burton toe to toe in Becket.

For what it's worth, Becket was also nominated for 12 Oscars to 7 for Lion, and they have the identical audience score at both IMDb and Amazon. I can't imagine anyone who loves Lion not loving Becket. AND there's a wonderful Blu-ray of Becket from the restored 2008 print. Definitely worth tracking down.

Also fwiw, included The Ruling Class and Becket among the top 5 O'Toole performances. I don't think I'm stepping too far out of line with either of them.

GREAT call on High Spirits! If my list was longer than 5, I'd definitely have included it. Definitely an overlooked late-career gem. Peter was the first to admit that he didn't have all that many of those.

Masada was definitely another. Again would have included it in a top ten.

The other one that I nearly included was Rogue Male, which O'Toole called his own favorite performance. Since I haven't seen it myself, it would have been solely on his recommendation...which maybe ought to count for something. He talks about it in this 2002 interview with Roger Ebert.

Here's the thing with My Favorite Year. I might like it better if I'd ever gotten to the end of it. After half a dozen tries, I still haven't. It just doesn't do anything for me, so in fairness, I might have to defer to someone who's managed to finish the thing.

Even if I loved it, it would have belonged exactly where I put it in this article, with Lawrence and Lion as among the movies that very nearly every O'Toole fan has already seen, and kept my attention to these other five as deserving more attention than they've gotten over the years.

And as you point out, there are a lot more than just five that deserve a closer look....
Re: The Five OTHER Peter O'Toole Movies That Thou Must See
by Chaim Mehlman
Have no comments on the others, but couldn't agree more about Goodbye Mr Chips. To me, from the first time I saw it on the big screen, it was an object lesson in how an actor could convince you he was someone else. He virtually became his character. Studying this movie should be part of every actor's training.

Related Articles / Tutorials:
TV & Movie Appreciation
Designing Tarantino's Once Upon A Time in Hollywood

Designing Tarantino's Once Upon A Time in Hollywood

Barbara Ling, production designer for Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, discusses how she was able to turn back time and recreate 1960’s Hollywood. Barbara and Go Creative Show host Ben Consoli discuss how Quentin Tarantino kept the film’s script a secret, how she restored Hollywood to the 1960’s, not using green screen, sourcing vintage props from eBay, filming the real Playboy Mansion, the challenges of filming on Hollywood Boulevard, and much more.

Ben Consoli
TV & Movie Appreciation
Great Effects for Good Omens: Collaboration with Milk VFX

Great Effects for Good Omens: Collaboration with Milk VFX

Wouldn’t you know it? You’re a demon living on Earth for the past 6000 years, and you’ve finally persuaded your angelic counterpart to help you stop the end of the world, and now you can’t remember where you left the 11 year old Antichrist. Such are the tribulations of Good Omens, the newly posted Amazon Prime Video series based on the beloved 1990 classic fantasy novel by Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman. We spoke with the Oscar, Emmy, and BAFTA-winning team at Milk VFX about how they brought this epic comic fantasy to life.

Tim Wilson
TV & Movie Appreciation
Gods, Marvel, & Maui: Making VFX on a Pacific Island

Gods, Marvel, & Maui: Making VFX on a Pacific Island

It's safe to say that there's no other VFX vendor in the world quite like capital T, let alone one that is constantly contributing to films like Marvel Studios' Avengers: Infinity War and Black Panther, as well as the critically acclaimed TV series, American Gods. What makes capital T unique is that they’re a two person, husband and wife team, who work from their home office ??" a beach house in Hawaii. You'll be inspired by what 2 people can do, if also a little envious of where they're doing it!

Feature, People / Interview
COW News
TV & Movie Appreciation
Avengers: Infinity War - Thanos, Titan, and Weta Digital

Avengers: Infinity War - Thanos, Titan, and Weta Digital

At the center of one of the biggest films in history, Marvel Studios' Avengers: Infinity War, stands Thanos, a CG character whose emotional range became a major contribution to the film's success. Creative COW Contributing Editor Hillary Lewis spoke with Weta Digital VFX Supervisor Matt Aitken about the challenges of their work on this remarkably compelling character and his world.

Feature, People / Interview
Hillary Lewis
TV & Movie Appreciation
VFX Legion Completes Effects for SUPERFLY Remake

VFX Legion Completes Effects for SUPERFLY Remake

Producer Joel Silver and Director X called on VFX Legion to tackle 100+ shots designed to amp up the impact of the raw violence in Sony’s reboot of the iconic ‘70’s film. The reboot of ‘Superfly’ puts a modern, stylish spin on the original 1972 film about a Harlem drug dealer trying to score one last deal before getting out of ‘the game.’ Set in present-day Atlanta, the Mecca of today’s popping music scene, the action is driven by a hip-hop soundtrack curated by Future. The city’s distinctive style is the backdrop for a new generation of affluent, extravagant drug kingpins that takes violence to the extreme.

Editorial, Feature, Project
VFX Legion
TV & Movie Appreciation
Star Wars: How Much Is Too Much?

Star Wars: How Much Is Too Much?

When Disney announced that they would be making a new Star Wars movie every year for at least 10 years I was both excited and a bit skeptical. In 2012 when Lucas sold his company to Disney for $4billion, he included his outlines of Episodes VII, VIII and IX. But Disney and Co. decided to discard these stories and start over, also discarding the extended universe of comics and books that millions of SW fans had grown to love. Adding JJ Abrams to the mix was icing on the cake for SW fans who have become critical of SW. But Lawrence Kasdan was the saving grace, who wrote a script for VII that the original actors could get behind. So, how much Star Wars is too much?

Review, Editorial, Feature
Mike Cohen
TV & Movie Appreciation
The Long Road Home with Seth Reed

The Long Road Home with Seth Reed

Seth Reed is the Emmy®-nominated production designer for the National Geographic miniseries The Long Road Home. Seth joins Go Creative Show host Ben Consoli to discuss the challenges and benefits of shooting at Fort Hood in Texas and how he created the biggest standing set in North America.

Editorial, Feature, People / Interview
Ben Consoli
TV & Movie Appreciation
Favreau, Technicolor & MPC Make The Jungle Book Come Alive

Favreau, Technicolor & MPC Make The Jungle Book Come Alive

Todd McCarthy, veteran film critic and historian, in his review of director Jon Favreau's new, stunning adaptation of Rudyard Kipling's The Jungle Book declared, "...the visual effects team led by Robert Legato and (MPC's) Adam Valdez has both created sumptuous settings that look as lifelike as any CGI ever presented in a studio feature and integrated both humans and animal characters in them in seamless ways."

Editorial, Feature
Jon Favreau
TV & Movie Appreciation
VFX Legion | Hardcore Henry breakdown reel

VFX Legion | Hardcore Henry breakdown reel

Remote post-production and visual effects studio VFX Legion has released its breakdown reel for the incendiary Hardcore Henry. The reel reveals the work that went into the first-person perspective action film, from augmenting violence to stitching shots together into one continuous sequence.

Editorial, Feature
COW News
TV & Movie Appreciation
Renaissance Masters Go 3D with Nuke

Renaissance Masters Go 3D with Nuke

VFX legend Steve Wright helped Italy's Sky 3D tackle an epic project, as Italian all-3D television station set out to present the city of Florence and the masterpieces of Renaissance art housed in the Uffizi Gallery in a spectacular stereoscopic 3D movie shown in 60 countries around the world. While the majority of the film was shot stereoscopically, Steve's challenge was to use Nuke to present some of the world's most precious artworks fully dimensionalized. Here's how he pulled it off.

Editorial, Feature
Steve Wright
© 2020 All Rights Reserved