LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open

COW Library : NAB Show : Bob Zelin : Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
CreativeCOW presents Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open -- NAB Expo Editorial


Orlando Florida USA
CreativeCOW.net. All rights reserved.


NAB2012 was a dramatic trade show. I credit this to the demise of Apple's Final Cut Pro 7, and the possible demise of the Mac Pro computer.

I say this because if FCP 8 had come out, people would have spent their $299 for it and nothing would have changed. But Apple had everyone asking, "What do we do now?!?" And so the scramble was on for Adobe CS6, Avid Media Composer 6/Symphony 6, and the big surprise, Smoke 2013. And there was SO MUCH Thunderbolt, all because of the threat of the demise of the Mac Pro, as people considered a future of nothing but iMacs and laptops.

Other people have been seriously considering a future on Windows, maybe for the first time, and looked at HP and ProMAX workstations because of this.

With no FCP 8, and possibly no more Mac Pro (a Mac with slots), everything changes. All kinds of companies, all over the show, were getting ready for a wide open future.


ENTERING THE SHOW: BLACKMAGIC DESIGN
Upon walking onto the show floor, we were confronted with the massive Blackmagic Design Booth. New product after new product was introduced, and the only reaction over and over again was: WOW!

The already infamous new product from Blackmagic is the new 2.5K Blackmagic Cinema Camera for a mere $2995. This includes the $995 DaVinci Resolve software as well as the $595 Blackmagic UltraScope software. If you value these products (as so many of us currently do), this brings the price of the actual camera down to $1500. All I can say is that I would not want to be on the waiting list for this camera, as it may incite riots.

So many of the Blackmagic products were shocking, mainly because of their price. The legendary Teranex converter was a great product at $90,000 just six months ago. Today, at $1995, all you can do is drop your jaw, and say "Excuse me?!?" And it's smaller and quieter than before, with new I/O options including Thunderbolt! For an additional $2000, you get the 3D version that can handle 4K images. This threatens the need for any other editing interface ever again.






To the pleasure of many, the previously "not very useful" Blackmagic HyperDeck Studio SSD recorder is probably the #1 desirable recording device, because it now offers recording and playback capabilities in both Avid DNxHD formats and Apple ProRes formats -- all for $995. Removable SSD drives mean you can record "forever" (just keep swapping them), and the "Pro" model can play back 4K from a single SSD disk for $1995.



Blackmagic HyperDeck Studio SSD recorder


DNxHD and ProRes recording are also available in the camera-mountable HyperDeck Shuttle, which starts at $345. If you already own the earlier version of these products, which used to record uncompressed only, you can add these new formats with a free software download.

As if they were not cheap enough already, Blackmagic Videohub routers have dropped in price. The new Universal Videohub series routers offer direct Thunderbolt inputs to the routers, where their signals can be distributed as HD-SDI to the rest of the crosspoints. Meaning: no need for a capture or output card for your Mac computer with Thunderbolt. In the same way I felt that AJA restarted my career when they released the AJA IO, and everything started to work with FCP because of that, I now feel that way about Blackmagic.

Countless people are calling me for new jobs, new installations, new systems, because all of a sudden, they can afford to put in routers, switchers, streaming systems, etc. -- all because of the low cost of entry from Blackmagic. The Blackmagic Cinema Camera will further this along, because it will make a complete, easy, inexpensive workflow for everyone, just as Blackmagic has already shown in other areas. And this keeps me employed. And this keeps me happy.


AJA VIDEO SYSTEMS
AJA, one of the most important companies in the modern video industry (and not just to me), released many new products. The "no brainer" this year is the AJA T-TAP. How do you get a modern iMac with Thunderbolt into your facility's HD-SDI router today? Simple -- AJA T-TAP. This tiny box plugs into the Thunderbolt port of an iMac or MacBook Pro, and converts this signal to HDMI and HD-SDI, so anyone can buy this $249 converter, and VOILÀ! instant edit room, compatible with all the popular editing programs from Adobe, Avid, and Apple.





Top: AJA T-TAP; just above: AJA Ki Pro Rack



AJA Ki Pro Quad
Avid Symphony 6 on laptop
Top: AJA Ki Pro Quad, and just above: Avid Symphony 6 installed on laptop
AJA also showed a critical new product, the AJA Ki Pro Rack. (This should have been released when they first introduced Ki Pro in 2009.) This puts the industry standard FW800 hard drive field recorder in a rack configuration, with dual FW800 drives, so it can fit properly into a machine room or remote truck. This product will be an obvious replacement for all the old Sony and Panasonic VTRs that are cluttering everyone's racks.

While I don't follow the 4K market closely, AJA showed the Ki Pro Quad. It records RAW 4K (as well as SD resolutions to ProRes) over SDI to SSD, and outputs it over Thunderbolt. It can be mounted to a camera plate system, like for the RED Epic or the Canon C500 4K camera. This incredibly powerful recorder is $3995, and can also serve as a converter for the production set's monitors.


THE "NOW" NLEs
In spite of Apple's current marketing, I am unaware of any professional in my area currently using Final Cut Pro X. Everyone sees that "the writing is on the wall," that we have to switch to something else. This has been my conversation every day: "Are you guys going to Adobe Premiere Pro CS6 or Avid Media Composer 6?"

Then, just before NAB, Avid announced Avid Symphony 6 for $999! That is, a crossgrade to the full Avid Symphony software if you own Final Cut Pro 7 or earlier (not X), and an upgrade to the full Symphony from any version of other Avid software editing software -- 83% off the regular price!

AND the Symphony special includes a full version of the amazing Boris Continuum Complete plug-in collection -- which by itself costs $1595! Insane!

Now in version 6, both Media Composer and Symphony can work with any AJA, Blackmagic or Matrox I/O product -- the first NAB where this was true. Will anyone ever again order an Avid Nitris DX or Mojo DX with these amazing choices?

BUT WAIT! There was an incredible third choice that EVERYONE was talking about -- the Mac-only Autodesk Smoke 2013! Autodesk was not even on my list of booths to visit, and boy was I wrong. They showed a completely redesigned version of this amazing all-in-one editing/compositing/effects software, oriented for video editors, running on an iMac no less -- for a mere $3495, reduced from $15,000! It ships this Fall, with a free public beta download available in June. The new battle between Adobe Premiere CS6, Avid Media Composer/Symphony 6 and Smoke 2013 is just beginning.

Autodesk Smoke for Mac 2013
Above: Autodesk Smoke for Mac 2013, click image to go to Autodesk website
With all of that said, almost everyone I spoke with said that while they are currently using FCP 7, they will most likely switch to Adobe Creative Suite 6 for their future editing needs.

This was not surprising, but came as a little blow to me, as I am an old school Avid Media Composer guy. I still think that Media Composer 6 is one of the greatest things that happened for our industry, and Symphony 6 is an incredible deal.

THAT said, while the buzz for CS6 was all over the show, the only Premiere editors I see out in the real world right this minute are those shooting with RED cameras, who desire the native workflow that Premiere offers.

Adobe Premiere Pro CS6
Above: Adobe Premiere Pro CS6, click on image to go to Adobe website
People will continue to use FCP 7 until they can't use it anymore. And I know exactly what dictates this decision: CAMERA FORMATS. The day it becomes just too painful to work with FCP 7 with your new-fangled camera, you'll say, "I can't take this anymore." This is why CS6 and Media Composer/Symphony 6 are so appealing, and FCP 7 is already too painful for many people -- one reason why Premiere's native support for so many cameras is so attractive.

It's just a matter of time, but people will do nothing until they have to. And when they do, as things stand today, it looks like most of them will be going to the Adobe Creative Suite.


STORAGE, STORAGE EVERYWHERE
So all of this stuff was in the big booths at the front of the South Hall, but once you moved towards the back, it was storage, storage everywhere. It was almost nothing BUT storage, and the associated companies for asset management and archiving -- and there are a lot of them.

Industry leaders EditShare and Facilis showed incredible, complete workflow solutions from ingest to archive -- EditShare with full 10gig Ethernet solutions, and Facilis with 8gig and emerging 16gig fibre solutions.

Upstairs in the south Hall, Avid showed the incredible Avid ISIS 5000 shared storage system, to which I previously gave a Creative COW Blue Ribbon Award. It uses standard Ethernet connectivity, with the option of adding 10gig cards for faster connections to Avid client computers. They also showed the Avid ISIS 2000, for massive amounts of nearline storage.

Additionally, Archion showed EditSTOR, which is a wonderful alternative for Avid storage workflow. Rorke Data also proudly displayed Strawberry, which is an incredible way to share Avid project files in Rorke's shared storage environment.

Studio Network Solutions showed their powerful SANmp shared storage software, which works with both Fibre and iSCSI for a SAN that doesn't require a server. While I was looking at this product, company owner Gary Holladay showed me the incredible globalSAN Xtarget Storage Server software, running on a Mac Mini. In conjunction with a Magma Thunderbolt 3 slot expansion chassis with the necessary cards to make it work, this becomes one of the smallest and most efficient shared storage enviornments on the market -- and certainly the most unique.


SANmp shared storage software interface. Click images for larger view.



Xtarget works with any direct-attached storage, including Thunderbolt and FireWire, and across global and cloud networks, so you probably don't have to buy any new storage to create an incredibly fast SAN server. You can see this amazing product for yourself with a 14-day free trial.

Of course, one advantage of this is the ability to now run SANmp software on an existing ethernet network to provide a volume-based shared storage enviornment for Avid Media Composer. After NAB, I tested this at Disney Broadcast Operations, and it seems to work great.

While volume-based shared storage is not the perfect solution for Media Composer, it does allow anyone who wants shared storage for Avid editing systems to do it at greatly reduced prices, without being at the mercy of Avid product line.

I personally look at a lot of the less expensive stuff. Maxx Digital showed their Final Share solution with 10gig direct connect. It uses the same parts that Avid uses for their own storage, but moves 800MB/sec to handle uncompressed 2K and 4K files over 10gig Ethernet in a shared storage environment.

Small Tree showed Titanium, a fantastic self-contained Linux server that houses drive arrays, making a great shared storage system that can work with every NLE on the market. And of course Small Tree, being a leader in 10gig connectivity, is able to do full 10gig direct connect to all client computers as well, for incredible speeds. Creative COW's Walter Biscardi -- who better? -- was on hand to demonstrate this wonderful system in the Small Tree booth all week.


Small Tree Titanium 16. Click image for larger view.


ATTO Technology ThunderLink
ATTO Technology ThunderLink Thunderbolt adaptor. Click image for larger view.
THUNDERBOLT STORAGE
Sonnet had their great fibre and SATA chassis at the show, as well as their new innovative Thunderbolt products. This included the xMac mini Server -- a rack chassis that holds a Mac Mini computer, along with a Thunderbolt to PCIe adaptor that can house normal PCIe cards to run big disk drive arrays, and even a Red Rocket. They also showed the Echo Express and Echo Express Pro Thunderbolt to PCIe expansion chassis -- both one and two slot, with integrated power supplies.

They also showed the Echo ExpressCard/34 Thunderbolt Adapter, as well as the ever-expanding line of QIO products. Sonnet swears that with the new firmware updates, the computers don't lock up when you pull the cards. I saw this proved at the ProMAX booth.

Maxx Digital showed the Thunderbolt version of the Mobile Rocket RAID for the RED Rocket card, which lets you use the RED Rocket in the field with new Mac Book Pros that have Thunderbolt ports. ATTO Technology is one of my favorite companies in this industry, and they showed the ThunderLink series of Thunderbolt adaptors to everything -- Thunderbolt to SAS/SATA, Thunderbolt to Fibre channel, and Thunderbolt to 10gig Ethernet. (Also in ATTO's booth: CI Design's new Thunderbolt to 8-bay SATA chassis.) ATTO is certainly aiding our industry's ability to continue to use all of our products, should the Mac Pro disappear.


PCs
This possibility has made people have been looking at PCs who would never have even considered them before.

I met with HP, who showed me the details of their new Z820 workstation. Oh my God! This is the computer that Apple should build, but never will. Sandy Bridge chipset from Intel with eight slots (four x16 lane, three x8 lane, and a legacy PCI slot), twice as much RAM as a Mac Pro can hold, and up to six SAS or SATA solid state drives in stock configurations, seven expansion bays in all.

The fact is, HP kicked ass. Other than a Dell in the Intel booth, the only PCs at the show were HPs. Everyone -- and I mean EVERYONE -- had a Z800 or Z820 workstation that was demonstrating a Windows 7 product.


ProMAX ONE, left. Right, HPZ820


With one exception. The ProMAX Systems booth showed the ProMAX ONE, a PC built for them by CI Design that looks exactly like a Mac Pro. It has six easily accessible drive bays from the front, 4 ports of Ethernet that support link aggregation, a built in LTO, a built-in Sonnet Qio for SxS, P2 and CF cards, and six slots -- four are x16 lane, two are x8 lane. If I switch to PCs, this is the computer I am buying.

As I'm writing this, I'm asking myself, "Are we all idiots? Why aren't we working on an HP Z820 workstation?" What I have seen really shows that IF we were to all switch to Windows 7 (which will never happen), this aggravation would be all over. AJA, Blackmagic, Matrox, Adobe, AVID ALL work on a Z820, and this would be a no excuse system. But nooooooo! Gotta have those Macs!



IKAN's D5w 5.6" HD-SDI LCD Monitor w/ Hi-Def Panel (Waveform)
AND MORE...
I wish that I had more time to go visit the other halls more extensively besides the South Hall. On my way to the Center Hall to see the Teradek Cube -- which is an amazing WiFi Transmitter for HD-SDI signals. I passed the IKAN booth, a company I would never normally even look at. They were showing their amazing new self contained waveform monitor/vectorscope/LCD Monitor display for camera rigs -- and this complete tiny package cost all of about $1200 dollars! This is why I always feel that there is never enough time at NAB -- because there are such wonderful suprises all over the show, and unless you are lucky enough to bump into them, you will just miss the entire exhibit.

NAB 2012 was such a unique show, because it reinforced that EVERYONE can own anything today, without having a huge fianacial investment in equipment. Everyone can afford hi-end finishing systems, HD monitors, scopes, color grading software, and now, even a 4K camera. The playing field is getting leveled more than ever before. It's an exciting time.

NAB 2012 only left me with one question: what will Apple do next -- and will it hurt?









Comments

Re: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Ian Liuzzi-Fedun
We're talking about that Magma unit which they stole from another company - yeah that one.

Re: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Ronn Kilby
Regarding the Hyperdeck Shuttle 2: "If you already own the earlier version of these products, which used to record uncompressed only, you can add these new formats with a free software download." I'm pretty sure this is not true. The original version only records uncompressed and there is no upgrade available.
@Ronn Kilby
by Tim Wilson
Hi Ron, you're right that this is a little ambiguous. While there are a number of other upgrades available for HyperDeck Shuttle 1 owners, including timecode and SDI triggering, the free format upgrade is for people who own HyperDeck Shuttle 2.

We'll edit the article to reflect that.

Tim Wilson
Associate Publisher, Editor-in-Chief
Creative COW Magazine
Twitter: timdoubleyou

@Tim Wilson
by Ronn Kilby
Thanks Tim. I didn't want anyone to make the mistake I did 2 weeks ago - I bought the shuttle version 1 (about half the price of version 2) then realized before I even opened it that it only did uncompressed and could not be upgraded. I returned it to B&H and paid the difference to get version 2. Now it looks like you can't even buy the version 1. But just in case, I thought it best to be clear in that regard.
Re: Article: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by jason carey
I have been using MC 6 and frankly I think it stinks.. its slow, and does not do simple 64 bit stuff like background rendering or GPU stuff. I would not write off FCP quite yet..but frankly, Media composer really dissapoints me. Its buggy and the interface is creaky as hell. It takes 8 seconds to create a new bin.. The nesting paradigm is old and still terrible. and AMA is weak.
Re: Article: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Matt Gottshalk
Totally the opposite of my experience on MC 6 running on a self-built Windows 7 PC.

Fast, stable, AMA works well, although for quickest editing you will want to transcode to DnXHD.

Avid's #1 media management is something Adobe could learn a thing or to about.

I edit Red 4k, P2, XDCam, and DSLR footage all day on it and it works well.

McGee Digital Media Inc.
24P HD Production and Post
http://www.mcgeedigitalmedia.com
Re: Article: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Bob Zelin
AVID Media Composer 6 is great and stable. I have always seen comments like this my entire career - "AVID sucks, only CMX is good" - then "FCP sucks, on AVID is good" - and now "Premiere 6 sucks, only FCP is good". Everyone learns "their" program, and then everything else sucks. I see this in every aspect of our business (only pro tools is good, only Grass Valley switchers are good" etc.).

No one wants to learn something new. That is where all these silly comments come from.

MC 6 with AJA Kona LHi on a Mac Pro - can't beat it (but Premier 6 is kick ass). Anything but FCP X !

Bob Zelin

Re: Article: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Jeremy Garchow
Bob-

Thanks so much for the report.

Next time, less politeness, more caps lock now that I am mature enough to handle it.

Enjoyed your NAB interview with Mitch, too.

Jeremy
Re: Article: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Michael Slowe
Hey you guys, I clicked on your forum by accident instead of my usual Media 100. I've been editing on Media 100 for over fifteen years now and can't understand why it never gets mentioned. Now Boris has it and has engineered all the updates it will surely do everything an editor needs. Boris Red is attached for all the fancy stuff. Don't grumble about FCP, try Media 100! Apple ditching the MacPro is a big grumble if it really happens. Half the world's graphics industry use them - surely Apple can't do that, even if they don't make a huge amount out of them.

Michael Slowe
Re: Article: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Afsheen Aziz
Totally the opposite of my experience on MC 6 running on a self-built Windows 7 PC.
Re: Zelinizing NAB 2012! Bob Zelin: The Future is Wide Open
by Chris Borjis
great article, thanks Bob!

Re: Bob Zelin's NAB 2012: A Wide Open Future
by Mads Nybo Jørgensen
Hey Bob,

Yes, great write up. Not sure about the whole Smoke thing - after a historical bruising experience with loosing my beloved edit* I just don't want to go back there. However, I am interested in your opinion on Lightworks and their new business model?

All the Best
Mads
London, UK
+1
Re: Article: NAB 2012: A Wide Open Future
by Chris Harlan
Great roundup. Loved the last line, to which, I can only add, "Indeed."
+1
Re: Article: NAB 2012: A Wide Open Future
by Bob Zelin
yea - do we really trust Apple to actually deliver a "new" Mac Pro in 2013. I certainly don't.

Bob Zelin

+2


Related Articles / Tutorials:
Autodesk Smoke
NAB 2012: Autodesk Unveils a New Smoke

NAB 2012: Autodesk Unveils a New Smoke

Autodesk introduced a new Smoke that features an editor-friendly user interface, connected editing and effects, lower system requirements and a much lower price. Aimed at the multi-tasking editor, the new Smoke allows editors to handle all kinds of visual effects tasks on the editing timeline.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
NAB Expo
NAB 2012: Broadcast Pix Debuts Video Control Center 3.0

NAB 2012: Broadcast Pix Debuts Video Control Center 3.0

Broadcast Pix is coming to NAB with new Video Control Center 3.0 software, which adds features and functions to Granite and Mica systems. Mica is showing for the first time in North America, after an IBC 2011 debut, and NAB attendees will also get a good look at VOX, voice-automated production.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
NAB Expo
NAB 2012: Adobe CS6 Release

NAB 2012: Adobe CS6 Release

With the release of Adobe Creative Suite 6 Production Premium, Adobe's booth at NAB 2012 was packed every day of NAB 2012. Editors in particular came to check out all the dramatic changes made to Adobe Premiere Pro, including a redesigned interface that makes it friendly to users of other NLEs.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
NAB Expo
NAB 2012 is in the books, final thoughts...

NAB 2012 is in the books, final thoughts...

Walter Biscardi went to NAB 2012 with every intention of documenting each day and sharing the vast (and often overwhelming) wealth of information he would glean from the NAB SHOW floor. Well, day one left him needing tons of caffeine, and a lot more sleep - so we're wrapping up now, after a flight home and some time for Walter to catch his breath.

Feature
Walter Biscardi
NAB Expo
NAB 2012: Blackmagic Design's Dan May Talks about The Camera

NAB 2012: Blackmagic Design's Dan May Talks about The Camera

While at NAB 2012, Debra Kaufman sat down with Blackmagic Design President Dan May to talk about the Blackmagic Cinema Camera as well as other news from the company, including Teranex 2D and Teranex 3D Processors, a new family of high-end broadcast standards converter processors, and a release of the Desktop Video 9.5 software update with support for Adobe Premiere Pro CS6 video software using Blackmagic Design's DeckLink, UltraStudio and Intensity capture.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
NAB Expo
NAB 2012: AJA Video Systems

NAB 2012: AJA Video Systems

AJA Video Systems brought out the big guns at NAB 2012, including T-TAP, a powerhouse in a small, inexpensive package for delivering 10-bit 2K, HD and SD (with embedded audio) from any compatible Mac. Elsewhere, the company released firmware to support Avid DNxHD and offered a post pathway for the 4K output of the new Canon C500.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
NAB Expo
NAB 2012: Avid

NAB 2012: Avid

Avid focused on broadcasters at NAB 2012, introducing Interplay Sphere, a cloud-based editing initiative, and a Multi-platform Distribution Platform for making it easier than ever to distribute to TV, web, social media and mobile. The company also unveiled numerous broadcaster-friendly products, including the AirSpeed 5000 server and Avid Motion Graphics. For the pure editing crowd, Avid unveiled a cross-promotion deal to offer Symphony's color correction and finishing capabilities for a fraction of its usual cost.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
Boris FX
NAB 2012: Boris FX

NAB 2012: Boris FX

Boris FX came to NAB 2012 with new versions, each of which expanded the capabilities of the company's toolset of visual effects, compositing, titling, and workflow tools: Version 8 of its flagship Boris Continuum Complete, Version 2 of Soundbite and Version 6 of Boris Graffiti. The company also announced support for Adobe Creative Suite 6 and Avid DS.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
SAN - Storage Area Networks
NAB 2012: ATTO Technology

NAB 2012: ATTO Technology

ATTO Technology showcased its entire line of storage and network connectivity products at NAB 2012, including its new Thunderbolt Desklink devices ThunderLink and ThunderStream. Also featured was a technology demonstration of the Celerity 16Gb/s Fibre Channel Host Bus Adapters (HBAs), the FastStream SC SAS/SATA RAID Storage Controller with 8Gb/s Fibre Channel connectivity to SAS/SATA storage, ExpressSAS 6Gb/x SAS/SATA Host Bus and RAID Adapters and FastFrame 10Gb/s Ethernet Network Interface Cards.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
Cinematography
NAB 2012: Anton/Bauer

NAB 2012: Anton/Bauer

At NAB 2012, Anton/Bauer, a part of Vitec Videocom, a Vitec Group company, debuted its QRC-CA940 Gold Mount solution for the new Canon EOS C300 digital cinema camera and also showcased the MATRIX Cheese Plate, a new mounting plate that can be used with the company's Gold Mount Solutions for the Sony PMW-F3 camera and NEX-FS-100; Canon EOS 5D Mark II, EOS 7D, EOS 60D Digital SLR camera and the EOS C300; Panasonic AG-AF100 series professional HD camera and RED EPIC digital cinema camera. The company also unveiled its Customer Support On-Site Maintenance Program.

Feature
Debra Kaufman
MORE
© 2016 CreativeCOW.net All Rights Reserved
[TOP]