LIBRARY: Tutorials Reviews Interviews Editorials Features Business Authors RSS Feed

Disk Drive Storage Systems: Where Are We Today?

COW Library : Media Formats | Media Capacities : Bob Zelin : Disk Drive Storage Systems: Where Are We Today?
CreativeCOW presents Disk Drive Storage Systems: Where Are We Today? -- Media Formats | Media Capacities Editorial


Orlando Florida USA
CreativeCOW.net. All rights reserved.


One of the most debatable and confusing issues for modern computer-based editing systems and graphics systems is disk drives. It's one of the most unglamorous subjects of our business, but it's something that everyone needs, and everyone owns.

Somehow, we keep buying more and more of these disk drives until they become obsolete and we have to start all over again!


THE EXPENSIVE OLD AND SLOW DAYS

Back in the stone age (about 20 years ago), people with early computer editing systems used SCSI disk drives, and they were expensive.

They were also small. The early "larger" SCSI drives were 600 megabyte drives but this technology progressed rapidly. Soon, nine gigabyte drives were available, at the small cost of only $5000 per drive. (Younger readers may think this is a joke, but this was no joke in the mid 90s.)

As other drive technology was developed, SCSI started to lose popularity, because they had bulky multipin cables that interconnected them, and they had to choose from among a handful of available device IDs. Did I mention that they were both inconvenient and expensive?


ENTER FIREWIRE/IEEE 1394

With the advent of the DV camera and its use of the IEEE 1394 FireWire bus, FireWire drives came on the scene. These drives were small and inexpensive, but were only useful for low-bandwidth video, specifically DV25. But Sony and Panasonic cameras supported the format, and people found FireWire drives great for use with it.

This is when the problems started to arise.


SHOUTING "FIREWIRE!" IN A CROWDED SUITE

All of a sudden, people couldn't understand why they couldn't use these inexpensive Firewire drives on their professional NLEs. They were disk drives, weren't they? But FireWire drives were simply not fast enough to digitize video with high data rates.

Then Apple introduced FireWire 800 (twice the speed of standard Firewire) on their new computers, and in turn, FireWire 800 drives came to market.

They were fast - fast enough to start recording video. This was the beginning of the end for SCSI drive technology, even though SCSI drives that were "striped" together were fast enough for multiple streams of uncompressed SD - or even HD.

No one cared.

FireWire 800 was cheap, and it worked.

As new compression codecs were introduced to the professional editing market, people started to realize that they could record all kinds of stuff with FireWire 800 drives, including formats like Panasonic's DVCProHD.

This continues today with Apple's new ProRes422 format, which can also be used with FW800 drives.

But Firewire 800 started to show its limitations fast. Drives would fail, drives would overheat, there were problems "looping" multiple FW800 drives together, so large drive arrays were a problem to create.

But that didn't stop anyone.

As FW800 drives dropped in price and increased in capacity, people bought more FW800 drives than ever -- often putting single projects on a single FW800 drive.


A NEW HOPE

Then Apple introduced the Mac G5. This had a new type of disk drive in it. a SATA drive (serial ATA). Big deal. It was a disk drive. Who cared?

But someone stuck another SATA drive into the spare slot of the Mac G5, and tried to record uncompressed video to it - and it worked! I couldn't believe this when I first heard about it, so I tried it myself, and it was true. SATA was fast like SCSI drives, and it was cheap.

But to me, a single internal drive was a short term solution. One company striped the two SATA drives together RAID 0, and you could do almost anything short of uncompressed HD.

I tried this on a Mac G5 at David Nixon Productions in Orlando in March 2005 (also the stone age), and we couldn't believe that we were flawlessly capturing uncompressed SD on a tiny, inexpensive box. It used to take 8 SCSI drives striped together to do that job.

This was just the beginning of SATA technology. It probably still is, as SATA is still one of the leading solutions for disk drive storage. The drives grew from 160 Gig, to 250 Gig to 500 Gig, to 750 Gig, to 1 TB drives, in a very short period of time.

When the 250 Gig drives first came out, you had to plug in one drive per SATA port on the disk drive cards. You could soon buy an 8 port SATA card that let you connect 8 drives.

Having eight 250 Gig SATA drives on a system was incredible at the time. The idea of having 2 TB of storage on a computer was almost inconceivable.

Soon, Port Multiplication was developed by a company called Silicon Image. This allowed up to five drives to be hooked up to a single SATA port on the SATA card.

Emterprising companies like Sonnet and Cal Digit started to make port multiplier cards, with four ports on them. Now, each port could run five drives, and you could have 20 drives on a single computer.

At the beginning of port multiplication, 500 Gig drives were available. That meant 10 TB of storage on a single computer with four five-bay boxes. The new 1 TB drives mean 20 TB per computer!

As drives became more efficient, and SATA host cards became better, it was soon possible to have 5 SATA drives stripped RAID 0 to do uncompressed HD.


PRACTICING SAFE STORAGE

The problem with stripping all these drives together was that they were all at RAID 0. RAID 0 means that the drives all work together to achieve maximum speed and performance - but if one of the drives fails, you lose all of your data.

This happened with SCSI drives, it happened with FireWire drives - and it now happens with SATA drives that use a simple RAID 0 stripping configuration.

There have been RAID-protected products in the past. RAID 3 was made popular by Medea and HUGE Systems (now Ciprico). These products had SCSI interfaces and used "old style" parallel ATA drives, internally stripped together. If a drive failed, you would not lose your data. Upon replacing the defective drive, the new drive would be rebuilt, and you would be back to your protected system.

Because SATA was inexpensive, and had amazing performance, everyone anticipated RAID protected SATA arrays. And sure enough, they were introduced this year (2007).

Companies like Sonnet, Dulce, Cal Digit, ATTO Technology and others used a new type of interface, called SAS (serial attached SCSI), that used the same inexpensive SATA drives, but now allowed them to be RAID protected, in case one of the drives failed.

There are some that will say "Who cares? You could do this years ago." People care because now it's cheap to do this! You can have enormous volumes of disk drives available to you that are RAID protected for very little - less than ever before.


SOMETIMES, MORE IS MORE

In the past year, I've observed people wanting more and more storage. Editors want their entire libraries on their disk drives for instant access.

The concept of "off line/on line" - where you would digitize your material at a low resolution, edit your job, and recapture your material at a higher resolution when you are done - that's pretty much over. With the advent of large disk drives, editors often digitize all of their video media at the resolution they will ultimately deliver in, and never recapture later at a higher resolution.

This had prompted the demand for expandable SAS SATA drive arrays - where you can keep adding more and more of these RAID protected SATA enclosures. These products, announced by companies like Dulce Systems and Cal Digit, are anxiously awaited.


BUT WHAT ABOUT SHARED STORAGE?

Avid introduced shared storage using Fibre Channel disk drive technology many years ago. They continued to develop this technology, into its current product, Avid Unity. This is the industry-standard for shared storage, and is used by countless TV stations and film productions around the globe.

There's only one problem with Avid Unity - its price puts it out of reach for most single users and small facilities.

Shared disk drive storage for video media is known as SAN or Shared Area Network. In practice, it confused many IT managers, much less owner-operators of small offices. Most couldn't understand why their computer network could not be used to share video media throughout their company.

The answer was simple: standard networks, even Gigabit Ethernet (Gig-E) networks, were too slow to handle the bandwidths required for professional video.

As other companies observed Avid's success with their Unity shared area network product line, they jumped on the bandwagon. They all started to show shared area network solutions that could work with Avid, Final Cut Pro, Premiere, and Pro Tools systems for both Mac and PC.

But people had gotten used to spending under $3000 for a local drive array. It pained them to realize that they would need to spend $25,000 to share video between two computers.

There are now software-only solutions for creating SANs. But the reality of purchasing two copies of software, two fibre channel cards, a fibre channel switch, and a fibre channel disk drive array is still too expensive for most users.

"Isn't there something cheaper?" is the common cry of countless editors and graphics people out there.


SHARED WISDOM

The misconception of SAN systems is staggering. Apple, one of the early developers of SAN systems, came out with a very nice Fibre Channel disk drive chassis that was RAID protected, called the Apple Xserve RAID.

To this day, I'm always asked if someone can do shared storage with this product, without having to buy anything else. The answer of course is "No."

So, when is shared storage the way to go instead of huge local storage and sneaker net?

The concept of shared storage is fantastic. One central drive array, everyone can access the information, make changes, and have the next editor/audio guy/ graphics guy work on the same material, at the same time.

The original concept was to have the assistant digitizing, while the editor started to cut the material that had been entered into the system. This grew into multiusers, including the graphics and audio workstations that would have access to the same material.

So why wouldn't everyone want this ?

The number one reason is easy: it's expensive. When 4 TB of storage is available for under $3000, it's very hard to convince someone to spend over $20,000 for the same amount of shared storage.

But there are other important reasons too. Products like FireWire drives made many users feel that they can buy a product, plug it into their computer, and voila!, they start working.

This is not the case with any SAN system. The system must be set-up and configured - which means that a trained and qualified person must do this.

Even if you can fake your way through the set-up, you'll ultimately get yourself into trouble - and potentially lose not only your media, but all the media for your company that's stored on the system.

The simplest systems use the Gig-E ports on computers to communicate with a switch built into the mainframe where the SAN drives are housed. But even these don't just "plug in and work." Once you look at them, they require the installation of a Fibre channel card in the computer, client software, configuration of a fibre channel switch - and connection to the main fibre channel array. This is never cheap. Think $8000 minimum just for the drive array, before you spend anything on the gear that will actually make it work as shared storage.

The more streams of video you need, the more bandwidth it all takes, the more arrays you need. Systems that do not require client software - like Facilis Terrablock - still require network configuration of the individual workstations.

Software-only products work without a metadata server, but once you have a larger system, say five computers, you will get into trouble without one.

So the relatively simple system becomes the same involved system that you would have with a more complex Apple Xsan or Avid Unity system.

The bottom line here, is that if you want to have three or four users doing multiple streams of uncompressed video per system, with multiple terabytes of storage (for all these rooms), you're going to spend a lot of money.

Like I said before, shared storage ain't easy, and it ain't cheap. That's why local storage is still king - for the moment.

But people want inexpensive disk drives that are easy to install, easy to use, and do everything!

With the advent of today's SATA technology, and the promise of widespread 10 Gigabit Ethernet in the near future for everyone, that dream is pretty much here, or just around the corner.

Just remember: whatever you buy today will be obsolete about three months from now.


Bob ZelinBob Zelin
Orlando, Florida

Bob Zelin is an old cranky video engineer that got his start in the professional audio business in 1977. By 1981, he was fired so many times, that no one wanted to hire him, so he started his own company in 1982. Today, Bob resides in Orlando, Florida, terrorizing southern editing facilities. He is nevertheless one of the industry's most respected systems contractors. You won't have to look hard to find him at The COW: he posts around 10 times per day across over a dozen forums.



Find more great Creative COW Magazine articles by signing up for the complimentary Creative COW Magazine.



Recent Articles / Tutorials:
Art of the Edit
Growing Up on YouTube: Video Production, The Next Generation

Growing Up on YouTube: Video Production, The Next Generation

Through accessible tools and ease of engagement, young people like Sabrina Cruz have been able to grow up on YouTube and find one another. Underneath the amusing titles and colorful thumbnails, her videos have drawn over 10 million views with thoughtful messages woven together with high production value and editorial skill. Dismiss her as just a YouTuber at your peril. It's not that she's after your job. It's that she's one of the young creators helping change the world with intelligence, wit, drive, and an infectious optimism. Are you keeping up?

Feature, People / Interview
Kylee Peña
Art of the Edit
3 Mistakes All Beginning Editors Make, And How To Avoid Them

3 Mistakes All Beginning Editors Make, And How To Avoid Them

In the latest edition of his enduring series "This Guy Edits", Sven Pape covers the three mistakes that all beginning editors make -- mistakes he knows well, having made them all in his own editing career. Fortunately, he's learned the fixes by now too, and shares the easy workarounds in a high-energy, humorous fashion that will have even the most experienced editors nodding along and smiling in recognition.

Tutorial
Sven Pape
RED Camera
RED IPP2: Real-World Looks At An Image Processing Revolution

RED IPP2: Real-World Looks At An Image Processing Revolution

Science is one thing, the real world is another, and yet beautiful things can happen when the two interact with each other. Our conversation begins with RED Digital Cinema's Graeme Nattress explaining the ways that RED's customers are shaping the company's new approaches to color science, as reflected in RED's new image processing pipeline, IPP2. From there, filmmakers Chris McKechnie and David Battistella get specific about how RED IPP2 has revolutionized their RED workflows, both in the field and in post. No hype here. Just the facts, plus some very pretty pictures, and, okay, more than a little bit of excitement in the lab, in the field, and in the edit suite.

Feature
Christine Bunish
Business & Marketing
Authenticity: The First Step to Stock Video Success

Authenticity: The First Step to Stock Video Success

His stock footage has sold to the tune of $7 million dollars over the past 10 years, earning on average over $30,000/mo. Here, Robb Crocker shares the specific steps he took, and that you can take too, to build a successful stock video business: free from clients, deadlines, and creative limits.

People / Interview, Business
Robb Crocker
An Open Letter to Incoming Women Freshmen in Media Programs, by Kylee Peña

An Open Letter to Incoming Women Freshmen in Media Programs, by Kylee Peña

A lot of so-called “open letters” on the internet address the outgoing graduates of programs. And while they should bask in the glow of congratulations and good luck because they worked hard, they earned it, and they have some serious challenges on the horizon, this letter isn’t for them. It’s for you: the young woman who is leaving high school behind and beginning your first year of college in the next few weeks. Read on as Hollywood workflow supervisor and president of the Blue Collar Post Collective Kylee Peña reminds you: You have so much ahead of you!


Creative COW
My Illegal Internships: An Oral History, by Kylee Peña

My Illegal Internships: An Oral History, by Kylee Peña

Sure, unpaid internships aren’t exclusive to post production; however, for some reason we’ve collectively decided that the single biggest way to prove one’s merit is by working in some capacity for free. It’s almost as if everyone believes that because they suffered the difficulty of doing often humiliating or degrading work for free, everyone else should too. There are certainly times that personal enrichment worth the sacrifice to work for free, but employers, do you know if what you're asking interns to do for you is even legal? Follow along as Kylee gives examples from her own past internships to highlight current requirements, and lays out some suggestions to a fairer, more productive future for everyone.


Kylee Peña
Adobe Premiere Pro
Adobe Premiere Pro: Edit Faster with Overlay Editing

Adobe Premiere Pro: Edit Faster with Overlay Editing

Editor, VFX artist, post-house owner, and plug-in developer Simon Ubsdell shows you how to edit faster and more easily using the very useful but not often known-about Overlay edit function in Premiere Pro. This Quick Tip tutorial also offers tips on grouping.

Tutorial
Simon Ubsdell
Art of the Edit
Always Be Editing: Sculptors & Bricklayers Revisited

Always Be Editing: Sculptors & Bricklayers Revisited

Do you edit like a sculptor, or like a bricklayer? It seems a simple enough question, but as longtime editor, post house owner, and VFX software developer Simon Ubsdell shows, the implications for how this affects the way you edit can be profound. His advice, regardless of where you land on the spectrum? Always be editing.


Simon Ubsdell
Audio Professionals
Hearing The Handmaid's Tale: Jane Tattersall's Sound Career

Hearing The Handmaid's Tale: Jane Tattersall's Sound Career

With Emmy, BAFTA, Motion Picture Sound Editors Golden Reel, Canadian Screen, and Directors Guild of Canada Awards among many more, Jane Tattersall shares insights into a career in sound editing entering its fourth decade with two young women just beginning their own careers in the field. Their conversation begins with Jane's work on the Hulu hit series, The Handmaid's Tale.

Feature, People / Interview
Kylee Peña
Art of the Edit
Indie Film Sound Editing: A This Guy Edits Tutorial

Indie Film Sound Editing: A This Guy Edits Tutorial

ACE Award-nominated picture editor Sven Pape ("This Guy Edits") speaks with Sundance Award-winning sound editor Ugo Derouard on The 5 Five Steps of Audio Post Production: Sound Editing, Spotting, Dialog Editing, Sound Design, and Sound Mixing, paying special attention to the specific needs of, and techniques that can work best for, independent filmmakers.

Tutorial
Sven Pape
MORE
© 2017 CreativeCOW.net All Rights Reserved
[TOP]